[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Yes! I want to discuss all of them! (NT) -- FranS, 10:00:06 08/19/06 Sat
• Yes please! (NT) -- ElaineP, 13:20:03 08/19/06 Sat

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• I think the combination of DK and PinF are so powerful and intense that a break is warrented (unless you're on a roll, like Lady Tait!). I loved this book. The setting is so rich and exotic that I really had a sense of place with this one more than the others. DK is still my favorite so far though, for shear jaw-dropping revelations. I found myself walking down the hall, thinking>>>>>> -- FranS, 22:26:13 08/16/06 Wed
  • Will second your motion on the guided CM reread following Trinity. (NT) -- ElaineP, 08:39:36 08/17/06 Thu
  • I kept reading through sheer determination! PiF was so emotionally charged! I found RC to be a much easier read, no tear-jerking, heart-wrenching scenes, etc. A discussion of "Checkmate" sounds good to me too. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 09:58:19 08/17/06 Thu
• I think we could probably go ahead after 'Trinity' and do a guided read here on the Chessboard of CM. I remember almost feeling as though I'd had far too much rich food and was exhausted after 'PinF' and I knew I had to take a break for a bit. As hard as it was to do so. I remember sitting at the kitchen table drinking tea all those afternoons while my girls napped, reading Lymond. I think I hustled through my day in anticipation of those couple hours of reading. (NT) -- celtgirl, 10:03:04 08/17/06 Thu
• Comments on Marthe, please>>>>>>> -- FranS, 14:43:38 08/17/06 Thu
  • Everyone told me to just wait and see, so now I get to tell it to you!! Actually I'm about 1/2 way through Checkmate and there's still much to clarify. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 18:02:53 08/17/06 Thu
  • Marthe>>> -- celtgirl, 19:04:05 08/17/06 Thu

• Oh geez, sorry. I forgot what I was doing! Come inside now>>>> -- Tracy, 20:13:08 08/16/06 Wed
  • I think Lymond got caught up>>>>>>> -- FranS, 22:37:05 08/16/06 Wed
    • I was worried that him drinking so much would give the killer a chance to murder the little Queen. Didn't anyone think he was being careless? Did he have a back up to watch out while he was drunk? (NT) -- Tracy, 09:55:47 08/17/06 Thu
• DONT SCROLL DOWN! I MIS-POSTED AND SPOILER ALERT. Sorry! (NT) -- Tracy, 20:15:30 08/16/06 Wed
  • Spoiler has been deleted (and I managed only to read enough to be intrigued..........) (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 21:45:51 08/16/06 Wed

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Questions and comments -- Lady Tait, 09:48:19 08/12/06 Sat
  • I am with Sallie- I think the rest of the series will answer your questions, and I wouldn't want to spoil any of the discovery for you>>> -- celtgirl, 16:41:57 08/12/06 Sat
    • It probably took 12 hours for the knot to leave my stomach and the urge to spontaneously cry diminish. An afternoon looking for reno ideas in showhomes was good for that at least. That was gut wrenching stuff!>>> -- Lady Tait, 20:43:22 08/12/06 Sat
      • I was feeling hormonally-challenged as well, which wasn't helping matters! Almost finished TRC now, a day with major mentrual cramps left lots of time to read. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 13:20:57 08/14/06 Mon
        • Wow you are moving through the series at breakneck pace. I had to take a break after 'PinF' during my first read, I think I was emotionally fatigued. :) (NT) -- celtgirl, 14:44:29 08/14/06 Mon
        • OK girl, slow down!!! I feel totally slow!!! I started the Lymond chronicles 1.5 years ago and have been moving through them as fast as I can. I'm still reading Here Be Dragons right now and then it will be time for Trinity! I usually take a break after a DD book as they are so rich and huge and they take some time to digest a bit. At this rate I won't even get to the RC until late Sept. I feel like the slowest reader ever!! It may have something to do with the 4 kids and the working full time thing!! I need to take a leave of absence to get caught up on my reading. Glad you are enjoying the series so much. I envy you your reading time and speed! Cheers. (NT) -- Carolyn C, 15:22:34 08/14/06 Mon
        • I start back to work in 3 weeks, I work for the local school board, and I told myself I wanted to finish the series before "Trinity", hence the speed. I also have older teenagers so little time is involved except the usual cooking and cleaning. My house also looks a mess! I know I will have to read again to get more of the nuances, but once I start something, by hell or high water, I'm gonna finish it! I read "Here Be Dragons" in the spring before GoK and will get back to that series sometime in the fall I hope. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 15:57:34 08/14/06 Mon
• Forgot the >>>, please go inside above reply. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 09:49:41 08/12/06 Sat
  • Great questions, Lady Tait, but I am afraid you must continue the journey to find the answers. :) And I can certainly sympathize regarding the emotional toll Dunnett's books extract. She is a master at striking the deepest chords within us all. (NT) -- Sallie (), 10:55:28 08/12/06 Sat
• FRAN- just wondering how the 'PinF' read is going for you? Have you started it yet? (NT) -- celtgirl, 15:41:03 08/14/06 Mon
  • Yes, I've been reading like crazy, but Lady Tait caught up and passed me!! I'm busy falling in love with Jerott actually and being surprised quite often as usual. I'm loving it and am in awe at her ability to weave the plot lines so deftly and do so much in such really average sized books. It's like watching an Indiana Jones movie where more happens before the title than most entire movies! I'm having lots of trouble with my Dad and his galloping dementia and my sister and I decided over the weekend to place my parents in the nursing home that is about 3 blocks from my house. Will do that next week. He's getting up multiple times at night and is especially confused in the evenings. He already thinks he's in some kind of nursing home, so it's time. It won't really matter to mother since she is so unaware already, but......it really matters to me. (NT) -- FranS, 21:15:15 08/14/06 Mon
    • Oh Fran I'm so sorry- it seems to have moved so quickly from the time you were noticing the signs. (((Fran and mom and dad))). You're such a good daughter and have been so strong, I hope that things go as smoothly as they can in a situation like this. (NT) -- celtgirl, 22:54:11 08/14/06 Mon
    • Hi reading buddy!! I'm so sorry to hear you are having such diffuculties on the home front. I can't imagine caring for ailing parents, what a physical and emotional strain it must be. You are making the right decision, they need round the clock care and you are only one person. On the reading front, you can read my comments above when finished PiF, I just finished RC last night and some of the questions are answered! (NT) -- Lady Tait, 09:15:59 08/15/06 Tue
      • Wow! You really ARE blowing through these! I'm looking forward to reading all the comments. After reading your earlier post about how distraught you were with the ending, I put the book down last night when it started getting very intense. Don't need anything else keeping me up! I don't know how in the world Lymond is going to get out of this one. My only clue is that it may involve something underground. Thanks for the kind thoughts. (NT) -- FranS, 10:46:03 08/15/06 Tue
• CELTGIRL or SALLIE!! Questions about RC!! Please come inside>>> -- Lady Tait, 09:33:45 08/15/06 Tue
  • My thoughts on this>>>> -- celtgirl, 09:46:32 08/15/06 Tue
    • The "falling in love" scene in RC is a great, great moment in literature. Hands down. No debate. Simply perfection. (NT) -- Rosamond, 12:21:39 08/15/06 Tue
  • Lady Tait, my two cents>>> -- Rosamond, 12:12:45 08/15/06 Tue
• Rosamond I completely agree>>> -- celtgirl, 12:23:31 08/15/06 Tue
  • Thanks for the comments>>>> -- Lady Tait, 17:29:03 08/15/06 Tue

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• LucyAnn's question is in inside >>>>>>>>>>>>>> -- LadyPeggyB, 08:21:05 08/11/06 Fri
• I'll have a go of it, Lucy Ann. Inside >>>> -- Sallie, 11:05:30 08/11/06 Fri
  • Thanks Sallie..... -- LucyAnn, 05:28:08 08/12/06 Sat
    • Lucy Ann, I wonder if perhaps he had a better understanding than most. >>>> -- Sallie, 14:07:06 08/13/06 Sun
• I haven't looked yet, what part of the book is the question about? The ending? I'm not there yet, so I don't want to peek. (NT) -- Tracy, 16:14:05 08/11/06 Fri
  • Better wait Tracy....but hang on, the last 100 pages are quite an exciting ride. (NT) -- LucyAnn, 05:29:31 08/12/06 Sat
    • Thanks Lucy! I thought the same thing about the last part of GoK. (NT) -- Tracy, 07:43:28 08/12/06 Sat

Last edited by author: Tue August 08, 2006 22:08:15   Edited 1 time.
[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Dang, posted outside again!! Question inside>>>>>> -- FranS, 22:09:30 08/08/06 Tue
  • This is one of DG's favourite series actually, which was a place I heard about it other than my friend Deb. >>>> -- celtgirl, 23:26:41 08/08/06 Tue
• SALLIE- in case you don't go inside my post, I'd love to know your thoughts on this particular scene. I'm afraid I'm not helping Fran out here at all. (NT) -- celtgirl, 23:28:49 08/08/06 Tue
• Fran, I think you will find your answer on Page 138. >>>> -- Sallie (), 05:51:15 08/09/06 Wed
  • Bingo!>>>> -- FranS, 10:07:29 08/09/06 Wed
    • He is the Roger, isn't he?! Inside for a few thoughts. >>> -- Sallie, 10:30:44 08/09/06 Wed
      • Ooh, chilling thought! (NT) -- FranS, 15:07:31 08/09/06 Wed
• Haven't reached this far yet, and cannot speak to the sweet basil reference, but as for spikenard>>> -- ElaineP, 08:04:13 08/09/06 Wed
  • ummhumm. (NT) -- FranS, 10:09:10 08/09/06 Wed
• You're ahead of me Fran. I paused in my reading of LC to indulge in some light romance and reading of PiF has been slow since I've had things to do. Can't always read, even if I would prefer it. This morning I spent quite some time trying to patch my copy of PiF together. It's a used book, though most I buy are in relatively good condition, but the binding is not holding in this one (Eagle Publications) and pages and huge chunks of pages are falling out. How aggravating!! I only paid $1 fo it so no great loss as long as I can eventually find a repalcement. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 10:22:53 08/09/06 Wed
• Replacement that is! (NT) -- Lady Tait, 10:24:01 08/09/06 Wed
• I suggest you don't read this book in public places! I just spent some time reading in the doctor's waiting room and thank goodness it was nearly empty because I was rolling my eyes and giggling like crazy, trying not to laugh out loud! Someone contact the circus! I could just see this playing like a movie in my mind. Why has this series never been filmed....it may be too tough for anyone in Hollywood to read perhaps. (NT) -- FranS (still smiling), 15:13:13 08/09/06 Wed
  • I just finished reading about the fate of Oonagh, I'm not laughing right now! Ugh! (NT) -- Lady Tait, 15:34:40 08/09/06 Wed
    • Yes,>>>>> -- FranS, 16:46:01 08/09/06 Wed
    • Definitely laughing now>>>>> -- Lady Tait, 09:54:47 08/10/06 Thu
      • Yes, I'm loving it and Marthe's identity is quite intriquing and will be explosive I would suspect. Will be away from the computer till Sun and will check this board as soon as I get home! I love these discussions! (NT) -- FranS, 12:24:07 08/10/06 Thu

• I've been following that thread too Elaine, it's been utterly fascinating. I'm not sure my summer brain, nor my smattering of Greek mythology is up for it- but I've been saving the threads in case others here wanted to see them once they are done the series. (NT) -- celtgirl, 17:09:53 08/08/06 Tue
  • I remember so little about mythology from high school but I'd be willing to do some studying up. Or maybe we could just post some of the Marzipan comments here? I can't help but think that DD may have had mythological characters in mind when she created the series after reading about all the similarities. (NT) -- ElaineP, 17:14:24 08/08/06 Tue
• I don't think I can handle another board to monitor, but I would love to read some of the excerpts. Don't know much about mythology (I believe that's a song lyric!), so I wouldn't have anything to contribute. (NT) -- FranS, 19:13:17 08/08/06 Tue
  • Well, to be perfectly honest, I don't know why I'd even want to do this - as if any of us has the time for one more thing! It's just so interesting. I've opted for a kids' website that describes each god and goddess in easy-to-understand language, which is all I can handle anymore. (NT) -- ElaineP, 07:37:01 08/09/06 Wed
• Elaine, I started following this thread on Marzipan soon after Cindy emailed me several excerpts from it. Absolutely fascinating, if not a bit intimidating! (NT) -- Sallie, 06:07:14 08/09/06 Wed
  • Yeah, intimidating's the word! Those folks scare me, they're so knowledgeable. Still, I do enjoy reading the posts. I've learned so much there. (NT) -- Rosamond, 06:19:30 08/10/06 Thu

• Sorry, there it is! (NT) -- FranS, 13:11:33 08/07/06 Mon
  • Sometimes the board seems to go away, a quick post usually brings it back! (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 16:07:42 08/07/06 Mon
• DISORDERLY KNIGHTS.......Anyone want to discuss Gabriel and Joleta? >>>>>> -- FranS, 15:54:24 08/08/06 Tue
  • Regarding Joleta>>> -- celtgirl, 19:20:59 08/08/06 Tue
    • She never tells us......... -- FranS, 19:54:20 08/08/06 Tue
      • I think it was simply a matter of him piecing a bit of this together and a whisper of that. I always thought Lymond sensed that>>> -- celtgirl, 20:02:46 08/08/06 Tue

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Lymond's disguise, come inside >>>>>>>>>>>>>> -- LadyPeggyB, 09:31:06 08/07/06 Mon
  • My take..... -- LucyAnn, 11:14:57 08/07/06 Mon
    • LOL, I too went back and reread, looking for clues I might have overlooked the first time through.........come inside>>>>>>>>> -- LadyPeggyB, 11:26:44 08/07/06 Mon
      • I went down the garden path also.......... -- FranS, 11:42:18 08/07/06 Mon
      • Better to be "in" than suckered....inside -- LucyAnn, 11:46:30 08/07/06 Mon
        • This is demanding reading, no doubt. I'm in too much of a hurry to want to see what will happen next to look up all the unfamiliar words and references. These are like DG's books in that way. They can definitely stand up to multiple rereads to catch the subtlties and little clues. I think I've _maybe_ caught one in Pawn and am holding it fast in my shallow memory pool to see if anything comes of it. (NT) -- FranS, 12:05:39 08/07/06 Mon
          • Fran, I agree with you totally. I find myself rushing to find out "what's next?". And I've been late back from lunch a few times lately because once you start reading one of those action sequences, it's really hard, make that impossible, to stop until you get everyone through. The rooftop race, for example. DD really grabs your attention and just won't let go. (NT) -- LucyAnn, 12:21:43 08/07/06 Mon
  • My comments>>>> -- Tracy, 15:16:27 08/07/06 Mon
• You are safe with reading the Queen's Play post below as long as you have read thru ch. 2. Just stop at the Lennox question. (NT) -- FranS, 11:59:19 08/07/06 Mon
• When he scampered up the ship's mast>>> -- celtgirl, 12:37:29 08/07/06 Mon
  • He did get up there pretty quick, >>>>>>>> -- FranS (), 13:02:17 08/07/06 Mon
  • Good point! I spaced on that one!! (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 16:09:24 08/07/06 Mon
• A different question. About Oonagh>>>>> -- Tracy, 15:22:19 08/07/06 Mon
  • About Oonagh>>> -- celtgirl, 17:51:51 08/07/06 Mon
    • Another question if I may>>>>> -- Tracy, 18:22:10 08/07/06 Mon
      • I don't know exactly where it's stated Tracy>>> -- celtgirl, 18:29:07 08/07/06 Mon
        • She does seem quite walled off and bitter. Her only love seems to be her country, although I think she is touched with how repectfully O'Liam treats her. It was her aunt who said she was visiting and the aunt wished to find her a husband. I don't think O. had anything like that in mind. (NT) -- FranS, 18:55:14 08/07/06 Mon
  • How about another O question.... -- LucyAnn, 19:10:12 08/07/06 Mon
    • Lucy- can you tell me the serenade you're referring to? If you have a page, or a page that references back to the original instance it would help greatly, and then I might be able to come up with some sort of answer. I read through them all and now am going through Niccolo so things are a bit jumbled in my head. :) (NT) -- celtgirl, 20:05:51 08/07/06 Mon
    • Lucy, the explanation for the serenade can be found on Page 339 of the Vintage edition. >>> -- Sallie, 20:51:18 08/07/06 Mon
      • Thanks Sallie. I actually read this passage this morning before work and what some folks thought was sunrise was actually the big light going off in my poor little peabrained head. OHHHHHH, now I get it. (NT) -- LucyAnn, 05:25:13 08/08/06 Tue
      • Oh my goodness! I was wondering why it was such a no-no too and I completely missed why! I'll have to go and re-read that part. (NT) -- Tracy *slapping a very sore forehead*, 11:30:26 08/08/06 Tue

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• I am glad to see>>>>>> -- FranS, 21:50:36 08/04/06 Fri
  • Intense is the word for DD, I agree Fran. PiF is my favorite in the series. You're in for one of the great reading rides of your life! (NT) -- Rosamond, 04:54:59 08/05/06 Sat
    • Another thought. . .I'm glad you brought up the comparison with Gabaldon. It's something I've thought alot about>>> -- Rosamond, 05:28:37 08/05/06 Sat
      • I do agree with you mostly. I think DD is more "literary" and her stories are tighter and consistent from start to finish. And yet, I love Jamie more than Lymond. I feel a bit more distance with Lymond. I don't know the color of his eyelashes or what he's thinking and feeling. He's intriquing and exciting in a way that's different from Jamie, but he's not as real to me. This is my first read of the Lymond Chronicles and I will definitely read them again... and again...over time and perhaps my opinion may change. They are quite different series, but both excellent. I just feel like J&C are part of my family and I don't with the Lymond crew. I do think that DD packs more suspense, intrique, and plot twists, shocks, and excitement into her books than DG. And in fewer words. I really see the Lymond Chronicles as mysteries as well as historical fiction. I'll be interested to see what others think too. (NT) -- FranS, 09:03:41 08/05/06 Sat
• To me the two series are sort of apples and oranges- the intent of the authors is different and of course so are the stories. It's no secret that the Lymond Chronicles are my favourite series however I realize that they aren't accessible for all readers- I don't mean physically accessible, but as a reader. The prose is fairly knotty at times and so not everyone will like these books. I tend to not compare authors anyway, I like so many for different reasons. I think Dennis Lehane is one of the best writers I've ever come across and yet because he writes mysteries and thrillers many people miss out on him. I think every writer adds something to the tapestry of my reading experience. That's not to say I don't prefer some books over others, but rather I guess that I'm glad I get to read them all. That I get to spend time with Lymond and continue to follow Jamie and Claire and their adventures. (NT) -- celtgirl, 11:19:22 08/05/06 Sat
• I decided to read a bit of fluffy romance before starting PiF. Sounds like I should now "get at it"! (NT) -- Lady Tait, 15:54:38 08/05/06 Sat

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Just keep reading, Lady Tait. Just keep reading! :) (NT) -- Sallie, 11:18:40 08/01/06 Tue
• Everyone I've known who've read the books has the same reaction Lady Tait. Sallie's right--just keep reading. (NT) -- Rosamond, 13:31:39 08/01/06 Tue
• This, for me, is part of the pull of Lymond. Just when he's got you in the palm of his hand he behaves like an utter bastard and you are reeling again. I will third the chorus here- just keep reading!! (NT) -- celtgirl, 14:00:37 08/01/06 Tue
  • So it's going to be like the first book, and all erratic behaviour will be explained and exonerated? (NT) -- Lady Tait, 15:33:13 08/01/06 Tue
    • Finished the book this morning - all I can say is - what a wild ride! (NT) -- Lady Tait, 12:20:43 08/02/06 Wed
      • I think it's my favorite so far. She fools me every time! (NT) -- FranS, 13:45:46 08/02/06 Wed
        • I have to say I really cannot wait for you ladies to read 'Pawn' then- 'Checkmate' is also just wonderful. I love the whole series but those two are my especial favourites. (NT) -- celtgirl, 19:02:49 08/02/06 Wed
• What chapter is this, I want to read it again. I remember feeling just like you, but I don't remember why! (NT) -- FranS, 19:36:54 08/01/06 Tue
  • Fran>>> -- celtgirl, 19:38:20 08/01/06 Tue
    • Oh, right! That's the one I emailed you about and would have called if I'd had your number! No, I haven't started Pawn yet, am finishing up a Geo. R.R. Martin that's very good. It''s next. (NT) -- FranS, 21:33:10 08/01/06 Tue
• DK questions, Part I (to page 38 only, no spoilers beyond)..... -- FranS, 08:47:46 08/02/06 Wed
  • Inside for my answers>>> -- celtgirl, 12:02:52 08/02/06 Wed
    • 1. True, but don't you think >>>>>> -- FranS, 13:01:18 08/02/06 Wed
      • Fran about number one>>> -- celtgirl, 13:04:57 08/02/06 Wed
        • Got 'cha. I think DD does a really marvelous job in the first 14 pages in setting up the atmosphere for the book. She reintroduces us to some characters and starts the intrigue to come with new ones and reminds us of the history, while at the same time she makes it fun with these >>>>>> -- FranS, 13:19:55 08/02/06 Wed
          • Oh no, no need to edit. I think if we're posting inside and someone goes inside they are taking the risk of spoilers. Plus I think those of us hanging out on this board are either further than this in the series or have finished it altogether. So no worries. (NT) -- celtgirl, 13:22:53 08/02/06 Wed

• That should read 'anyone who is reading/going to read'. Voy won't let me edit the post for some reason. (NT) -- celtgirl, 15:01:06 07/25/06 Tue
  • Ooooo, I would love to get my hands on a copy of that! How might one get a copy? I can understand how you spent loads of time poring over it Cindy. Let us know how to get one. Thanks. (NT) -- Carolyn C, 03:58:56 07/26/06 Wed
    • Carolyn you can find them at www.DorothyDunnettReadingAids.com - I will say though that there are a few spoilers contained in the family tree, and a few shockers that I had no clue about even after reading all the books. (NT) -- celtgirl, 09:43:27 07/26/06 Wed
• You're welcome, Cindy! Glad to hear that you are enjoying it as much as I am. :) (NT) -- Sallie (), 11:50:55 07/31/06 Mon
• Has anyone actually placed an order for the timeline and further info from the afore mentioned website? (NT) -- Lady Tait, 18:48:47 08/01/06 Tue
  • Lady Tait, I ordered several Niccolo/Lymond Family Trees and a Translation Guide through the website, and Nancy Wright mailed them out to me the same day. (By the way, the Translation Guide is great for quick references, but I find I prefer the Dorothy Dunnett Companions for the detail they provide.) (NT) -- Sallie, 06:16:43 08/02/06 Wed

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Come inside for the questions... -- Carolyn C, 04:36:22 07/26/06 Wed
  • Come inside for the answers, such as they are>>> -- celtgirl, 09:51:27 07/26/06 Wed
    • My take on the paternity issue. BEWARE OF SERIOUS SPOILERS>>>> -- Rosamond, 10:49:25 07/27/06 Thu
      • That's absolutely fascinating Rosamond, thanks so much for sharing this. Funny how things seem obvious once someone else points them out. I think I will never unravel the mysteries of these books entirely. (NT) -- celtgirl, 11:57:00 07/27/06 Thu
        • wow, I would never have picked up on those hints! Very interesting indeed. Thats sort of what I felt in my gut too (about the paternity). (NT) -- Carolyn C, 16:31:44 07/27/06 Thu
      • Great insight, Rosamond! Thanks. Here are a few thoughts of my own. >>>> -- Sallie, 11:38:18 07/31/06 Mon
        • I agree with you that this passage makes plain to us the "true issue">>> -- Rosamond, 07:25:26 08/01/06 Tue
          • Absolutely! And here is one more element that bears consideration. >>>>> -- Sallie, 12:32:22 08/01/06 Tue
            • And which leads ME to ask>>>> -- Rosamond, 13:14:49 08/01/06 Tue
              • Hmm, my thought on this>>> -- celtgirl, 14:05:54 08/01/06 Tue
              • Rosamond , inside >>> -- Sallie, 14:22:56 08/01/06 Tue
  • Carolyn, inside for Q.1 >>>> -- Sallie, 10:27:05 07/31/06 Mon
• I haven't started Pawn yet, but at least I have it now. I'm finishing up a book by Geo. R.R. Martin that I had started before I started on Lymond. How far do I need to read before clicking on your question? (NT) -- FranS, 10:31:12 07/26/06 Wed
  • You would likely need to have finished the entire book before looking inside. I don't want to spoil anything for anyone. (NT) -- Carolyn C, 10:37:46 07/26/06 Wed
• Just thought of another question>>> -- Carolyn C, 10:35:46 07/26/06 Wed
  • You really made me think much of the day on this one Carolyn>>> -- celtgirl, 17:17:22 07/26/06 Wed
    • My thoughts>> -- Carolyn C, 04:30:17 07/27/06 Thu

Last edited by author: Thu July 20, 2006 11:02:36   Edited 1 time.
[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Shoot! I just about posted the whole thing on the outside!! Hope no one saw it before I could get it off! OK, now inside>>>>>>> -- FranS, 11:04:58 07/20/06 Thu
  • When I knew>>>> -- celtgirl, 18:20:00 07/20/06 Thu
    • Same time as you celtgirl!>>>>> -- Lady Tait, 18:47:03 07/20/06 Thu
      • You two were sharper than me. >>>>> -- FranS, 19:49:29 07/20/06 Thu
• Thank goodness>>>>>>>>>>> -- Tracyg, 14:53:45 07/20/06 Thu
  • I actually didn't get that clue until I was posting my question! I don't think we're going to have a formal q&a like before, we'll just need to wing it. Your idea about posting the chapter in the subject line is good. Ch. 1>>>>>>>> -- FranS, 15:11:28 07/20/06 Thu
• This a message regarding QP and DK which I am now reading. Does anyone else have a hard time getting into the book at first because of all the new and foreign names (often multiple names for the same person) and getting everything and everyone straight detracts from the enjoyment of the story for a while? (NT) -- Lady Tait, 18:51:53 07/20/06 Thu
  • Calling the characters by several different names and titles is confusing and makes these harder to read than the usual novel. I'm glad for the list at the beginning of each book. I usually just keep reading and something will eventually click about who this is, but at times I have to look back a bit to see who's talking. Seems like this is something an editor would help a first time novelist correct, although I think it is something the reader kind of gets used to. I find her very good with action scenes. No matter how much is going on, I find I can see it playing out in my mind. I was especially impressed with that swordfight scene in GofK's. (NT) -- FranS, 19:41:09 07/20/06 Thu
    • I think this is one place that taking Russian literature in college helps me out, I got so used to each and every character having multiple names and having to keep the strands straight with all these big, unwieldy Russian books that it works in my favour now with other books too. I agree with Fran though in that I'm surprised that they didn't try to make that first book a little less dense and hard to read, simply because I've always wondered how many people that turned off ever reading past about one quarter of the way into 'Game of Kings'. (NT) -- celtgirl, 19:51:37 07/20/06 Thu
  • Oh yeah, that list of characters in the front of the books is indispensable. I also love DD's description of action, especially that sword fight in GoK, but must tell you that I got a little lost somewhere in the steeplechase. (NT) -- ElaineP, 20:02:43 07/20/06 Thu
  • Lady Tait, have you come across your namesake yet in DK? (NT) -- FranS, 23:06:00 07/20/06 Thu
    • Not there yet Fran, I switched my reading to "To Kill a Mockingbird" for the character study. Just finished that last night so back to DK. (NT) -- Lady Tait, 09:14:21 07/21/06 Fri
• A question about Margaret Lennox's comment to Lymond >>> -- ElaineP, 20:17:53 07/20/06 Thu
  • This is one of those references that I didn't understand either and let slide.>>>>>> -- FranS, 22:45:36 07/20/06 Thu
    • Sudden inspiration!>>>>>>> -- FranS, 23:02:35 07/20/06 Thu
      • Oh I bet you're right Fran- that's pretty brilliant for one o'clock in the morning. :) It would also explain the 'white-hot flash of enmity' between the men too. (NT) -- celtgirl, 23:11:15 07/20/06 Thu
      • Fran, that is very interesting. I hadn't thought of the monkey as "substitute." Caution!! The following is a QP SPOILER so enter with care>>> -- Rosamond, 07:58:21 07/21/06 Fri
    • My take on this Fran>>> -- celtgirl, 23:07:46 07/20/06 Thu
      • Great insights - thank you, Fran and Celtgirl. A clearer picture of Margaret's conniving (sp?) ruthlessness develops here as she makes this remark in the presence of her husband, Matthew. What a b**ch. Lymond's response to this is now even more intriguing. This is just one example of how we can benefit from others' interpretations. (NT) -- ElaineP, 06:03:53 07/21/06 Fri
      • Hmmm, good point. >>>>>>> -- FranS, 07:52:27 07/21/06 Fri
    • A different interpretation -- -- Sallie (), 09:13:29 07/21/06 Fri
      • Bravo, Sallie!! Thanks so much for laying that out in such a cogent fashion. I'm going to print this off to help keep the timeline straight. Nothing like a few facts to hone the speculation! I'm so glad we're getting a chance for more discussion of these books. I wish my local book club were this interesting.... (NT) -- FranS, 09:31:11 07/21/06 Fri
      • I'm still puzzled. . .come inside only if you've read Ringed Castle or don't mind SPOILERS>>> -- Rosamond (ann@latmos.net), 10:19:50 07/22/06 Sat
        • I am too Rosamond, I assumed (admittedly without paying much attention to the dates) that Lymond had cuckolded Matthew Lennox. There are too many barbed and pointed insults pointing in that direction. So I am confused on that point as well, and no doubt on many others as well. :) (NT) -- celtgirl, 11:11:28 07/22/06 Sat
        • More dates for the timeline>>>> -- Sallie (), 12:19:09 07/22/06 Sat
          • Your case is convincing. The dates don't lie! Thanks for making this easier for me to understand (I need it easy!) (NT) -- Rosamond, 06:15:10 07/23/06 Sun
          • Another one to copy off! Thanks. (NT) -- FranS, 13:01:51 07/25/06 Tue
      • This is a great time-line breakdown, thanks. I agree with how you interpret the 'Whose...' passage. That was my original thought, that either she actually questions the new heir's paternity, or mocks Lymond by suggesting such a thing. (NT) -- ElaineP, 13:59:16 07/22/06 Sat

• Hi Cindy, I'll use your post to move the questions up. Queen's Play, Ch. 2>>>>>>> -- FranS, 13:56:11 07/21/06 Fri
  • My answers inside>>> -- celtgirl, 14:57:08 07/21/06 Fri
    • I think O'LiamRoe and Robin Stewart>>>>>>> -- FranS, 15:10:55 07/21/06 Fri
      • Fran>>> -- celtgirl, 15:27:40 07/21/06 Fri
        • Oh and I agree>>>> -- celtgirl, 15:33:16 07/21/06 Fri
        • That's what I was thinking from something I picked up in DK. He is a flawed hero and very human, which makes him even more appealing. However, I didn't like him very much as Thady Boy. I like him much more in DK, which I finished last night at 2:30 AM! That book really interferred with my sleep! Pawn hasn't arrived yet, so I'm back with Geo. R.R. Martin and a bit of a breather. I'm leaving for a few days break in the morning, but will be back to catch up Tues. (NT) -- FranS, 15:36:51 07/21/06 Fri
          • Enjoy your time away Fran. PinF is such a beautiful book- if DK set you back and made you lose sleep, well just wait until you see what's in store for our Francis. (NT) -- celtgirl, 15:44:11 07/21/06 Fri
  • I can't find the pronunciation of Oonagh. Anyone know the correct way or is ew-nah right? I do know that Anne do Montmorency is pronounced Annay in case anyone cares. *g* (NT) -- Tracyg, 18:58:19 07/21/06 Fri
    • I think you're right in your pronuciation Tracy though I always just say 'oo-nah' in my head for some reason. (NT) -- celtgirl (), 19:40:22 07/21/06 Fri
      • Thanks, I dont know why I didn't google it earlier but I just found this site with sound to the names CLICKIT HERE (NT) -- Tracy, 20:05:46 07/21/06 Fri

[ Edit | View ]

Replies:

• Yipppeeeee!! I just picked up DK and the bookseller is going to help me find PinF - he told me he has a bookseller friend who is a Dunnett Nut and may have the book I need! He also had most of the Niccolo series as well as a first edition of GoK. Oh, and there was a first edition signed copy of Outlander for $650! Anyway....so happy to have a place to discuss the rest of the books with you all! (NT) -- Tracyg, 17:34:40 07/19/06 Wed
• All right! This is great. I guess we might start with Queen's Play and post most inside so we don't run into spoilers? (NT) -- FranS, 19:33:30 07/19/06 Wed
  • Fran, that sounds like a wonderful idea. Giddy-up!! (NT) -- Carolyn C, 06:39:04 07/20/06 Thu
  • Are we going to have a discussion of Queen's Play like that of GoK? (I just finished GoK and ran across the excellent discussion your board had - I hope I am not breaking rules by posting here). (NT) (NT) -- Robin, 08:21:24 07/20/06 Thu
    • Welcome Robin. This board will be for informal discussions. We may do a guided discussion on the other board in the future. Feel free to post away, as Fran suggested, spoilers should probably be placed inside. (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 08:26:17 07/20/06 Thu
• Hi Robin and welcome to our boards here! I think maybe we should just start a thread for Queen's Play and see if anyone has any questions. I re-read them all in June, so will have to go back and look, but if anyone has any questions and I think I might have some insight I'll be happy to answer. I do think we maybe need a bit of structure just to get going, so I'll do something this afternoon after my company leaves. (NT) -- celtgirl, 09:49:14 07/20/06 Thu
  • Thanks celtgirl, didn't mean to dump something else on your full-plate! (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 10:07:29 07/20/06 Thu
    • It's no big woop Peggy, I just thought I'd do something to get the ball rolling is all. I should have some time this afternoon. :) Are you preparing to roast this weekend? Hopefully you are not heading down Oregon way as the temps there are supposed to be up to 109 F. We are looking at 95-100 this weekend, ugh.... (NT) -- celtgirl, 10:52:00 07/20/06 Thu
      • I thought about going south before hearing the forecast. Called my Mom last night to make sure she's ok. We'll probably have to hunker down in the basement to keep cool here. (NT) -- LadyPeggyB, 11:36:17 07/20/06 Thu