Fair play, AK ... but 'stretching himself'? ... can't go along with that. This is the work of a man very much in a comfort zone, assembling a team of mates to poorly produce (again!) an album of half ideas ... This is akin to Weller in the late 80's with the death rattle of TSC. He should stop faffing about with pan pipes, flutes and violins, and strap on a guitar and give us his heart and soul ... something we don't see enough of on this album IMHO ... -- WHO BRINGS JOY

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4 ]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 23:33:55 06/04/08 Wed
Author: The Loved
Subject: Fair play, AK ... but 'stretching himself'? ... can't go along with that. This is the work of a man very much in a comfort zone, assembling a team of mates to poorly produce (again!) an album of half ideas ... This is akin to Weller in the late 80's with the death rattle of TSC. He should stop faffing about with pan pipes, flutes and violins, and strap on a guitar and give us his heart and soul ... something we don't see enough of on this album IMHO ...
In reply to: A.K 's message, "22 Dreams Review.." on 13:14:00 06/04/08 Wed

>Ive listened to the album a good few times since
>monday morning and can safely say iam loving it...very
>bold move to put out a double album in this download
>age, where people's attention spans are very short..so
>here it goes..
>1 Light Nights...
>Really lovely acoustic somg, some great guitar from Mr
>Cradock and would of fitted well onto AIN.
>2 22 Dreams, Should of been the opening song, great
>song LIVE aswell, very punchy.
>3 All I Wanna Do..Another middle paced song, and also
>very good live..
>4 Have you made up your mind.. The single off the
>album so far and the better song of the two
>IMHO..great riff and good vocals
>5 Empty Ring my second fav off the album, Simon Dine's
>fingers all over this song with a great drum loop and
>gets a great vocal performance out of P.W...superb
>song..and yet another great LIVE song.
>6 Invisable.. One of the weakest songs on the album,
>he's done to many of these plodding piano based
>songs..bit like Frightened off Illlmuation...BTW the
>demo version on the 2nd disc (Special Edition) is the
>better version.
>7 Song For Alice...nice bit of filler/ into to my fave
>track
>8 Cold Monets...very SCouncil..which is no bad thing,
>could of come straight off "Confessions" album sounds
>like it could of also come off LOVE Forever
>Changes....can't stop playing this...
>9 The Dark Pages etc...another interlude
>10 BVlack River Dident like this when it was the B
>Side to the PW/Coxon single last year, but fits very
>well onto 22.
>11 Why Walk When You Can Run... Sounds like it should
>of been on AIN...sounds like a B Side to me...so so..
>12 Push It Along...Should be the next single...fookin
>great song and sounds better LIVE
>13 A Dream reprise...
>14 Echoes Round The Sun...Still not to sure about this
>song, sounds half finshed to me...could be agrower
>though..
>15 One Bright Star Dident like this at first, but defo
>a grower...PW doing a waltz..unthinkable....but it
>works!
>16 Lullaby Fur Kinder..Nice piece of music...but would
>be better with lyices...skipping this at the moment
>17 Where'er Ye Go...wasted oppo IMHO needs a chorus,
>could be a better song, needs work
>18 God....bloody awfull child like poem...
>19 111...just a series of noises..
>20 Sea Spray......The one song on the LP that i wake
>up humming...must be a good thing...great tune...more
>like these please PW...
>21 Night Lites...Well what can you say but????????
>
>Overall a great piece of music, glad he is stretching
>himself and his song writing...as for gathering new
>fans i doubt it very much...could do with taking a few
>tracks off it and making it a really solid 16 song
>album....keep on keeping on!!

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:

[> I can see what your saying Lee, but i think those days are over mate...if he produces album of say the calibre of Neil young has over the last 10 year's i would see he's heading in the right direction.... -- A.K, 14:18:51 06/05/08 Thu

>Ive listened to the album a good few times since
>monday morning and can safely say iam loving it...very
>bold move to put out a double album in this download
>age, where people's attention spans are very short..so
>here it goes..
>1 Light Nights...
>Really lovely acoustic somg, some great guitar from Mr
>Cradock and would of fitted well onto AIN.
>2 22 Dreams, Should of been the opening song, great
>song LIVE aswell, very punchy.
>3 All I Wanna Do..Another middle paced song, and also
>very good live..
>4 Have you made up your mind.. The single off the
>album so far and the better song of the two
>IMHO..great riff and good vocals
>5 Empty Ring my second fav off the album, Simon Dine's
>fingers all over this song with a great drum loop and
>gets a great vocal performance out of P.W...superb
>song..and yet another great LIVE song.
>6 Invisable.. One of the weakest songs on the album,
>he's done to many of these plodding piano based
>songs..bit like Frightened off Illlmuation...BTW the
>demo version on the 2nd disc (Special Edition) is the
>better version.
>7 Song For Alice...nice bit of filler/ into to my fave
>track
>8 Cold Monets...very SCouncil..which is no bad thing,
>could of come straight off "Confessions" album sounds
>like it could of also come off LOVE Forever
>Changes....can't stop playing this...
>9 The Dark Pages etc...another interlude
>10 BVlack River Dident like this when it was the B
>Side to the PW/Coxon single last year, but fits very
>well onto 22.
>11 Why Walk When You Can Run... Sounds like it should
>of been on AIN...sounds like a B Side to me...so so..
>12 Push It Along...Should be the next single...fookin
>great song and sounds better LIVE
>13 A Dream reprise...
>14 Echoes Round The Sun...Still not to sure about this
>song, sounds half finshed to me...could be agrower
>though..
>15 One Bright Star Dident like this at first, but defo
>a grower...PW doing a waltz..unthinkable....but it
>works!
>16 Lullaby Fur Kinder..Nice piece of music...but would
>be better with lyices...skipping this at the moment
>17 Where'er Ye Go...wasted oppo IMHO needs a chorus,
>could be a better song, needs work
>18 God....bloody awfull child like poem...
>19 111...just a series of noises..
>20 Sea Spray......The one song on the LP that i wake
>up humming...must be a good thing...great tune...more
>like these please PW...
>21 Night Lites...Well what can you say but????????
>
>Overall a great piece of music, glad he is stretching
>himself and his song writing...as for gathering new
>fans i doubt it very much...could do with taking a few
>tracks off it and making it a really solid 16 song
>album....keep on keeping on!!

[ Post a Reply to This Message ]
[ Edit | View ]