VoyForums
[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

Wed, May 06 2026, 17:27:57 [ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, [3], 4, 5, 6, 7, 8, 9, 10 ]
Subject: Economics高手請進!


Author:
Gremlin
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]
Date Posted: 23:32:35 12/11/03 Thu
 Which of the following things can best be used as money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
1)tin of fresh coke
2)sea shells
3)fresh apples
邊個係答案丫=.=?教我~~~
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
多事的阿呆...
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 01:12:13 12/12/03 Fri
我認為是貝殼
因為其它兩樣東西太容易壞，難以收藏
難以保存的「貨幣」，有誰會要？
不過要貝殼做交易的媒介，也有點不方便
因為貝殼種類太多，難以統一計算
其實，中四的commerce和中六經濟的某課也有說的
不過我只記得那麼多...
[> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
唔係高手--BB
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 17:37:51 12/12/03 Fri
我個人都認為係貝殼...
但係有d人話sea shells係解貝殼類生物(注意係生物)...
所以可能係我o地解錯題...
不過如果唔係解錯題...
個答案應該係貝殼....
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
old boy
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 01:55:40 12/12/03 Fri
Just need to read the characteristics of medium of exchange.
i remember that they are listed in the text book
then you can make judgement of urself
actually it is just a easy question


>Which of the following things can best be used as
>money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples
>邊個係答案丫=.=?教我~~~
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
CMY
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 02:56:31 12/12/03 Fri
all of them CAN BE money in desert
but shel is the best
--can be kept for some time ....durable
--limited in supply(thus stable in terms of purchasing power of money ) ..desert is unlikely near to sea where seashells are abundant in supply
--convenient to carry ..ie. portable.
sea shells are smaller and lighter than apples and a tin of cokes
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
aa
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 09:51:44 12/12/03 Fri
but the ans is tins of fresh coke~~
[> Subject: 並非高手


Author:
hi
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 11:01:44 12/12/03 Fri
>Which of the following things can best be used as
>money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples
>邊個係答案丫=.=?教我~~~

我知道點解係1)tin of fresh coke啦，因為沙漠跟本就乜都冇，又點會用money作media of exchange，反而可樂又可以解渴、又可口，所以1)tin of fresh coke係最好。
[> [> Subject: Re: 並非高手


Author:
Gremlin
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 11:37:52 12/12/03 Fri
但係點用英文答丫......要比econ d reason先得架....
coke又大罐,又易壞...都得咩?
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
中五人
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 12:26:35 12/12/03 Fri
hi兄:
你好似係知左個answer再推番個reason出來,考試時根本就唔會選Coke,因為shell仲適合

我都係選shell
[> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
Gremlin
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 19:33:57 12/12/03 Fri
我都唔知點解唔係shell.....你岩都要比個合理既reason架...
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
aa
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 13:26:19 12/12/03 Fri
suggest solution is coke wo
i right
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
hi
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 19:25:55 12/12/03 Fri
我考試個時都係選shell，其實我都唔知個答案講乜，只不過估下點解係coke咋。仲有可能係沙漠好口渴個時，飲左罐coke，條命仔就durable d掛。(吹下水，不宜盡信)
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
F.3
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 23:02:03 12/12/03 Fri
我F.3架ja, 入黎玩下姐,
我覺得係coke, 因為沙漠冇金錢制度, 要以物易物, 而係沙漠度, 貝殼甘本冇用, apple就係搵唔倒, 如果帶去, 帶到去都壞左, 起碼coke冇咁快過期啦........

我F.3架ja, 入黎玩下架ja.....唔好笑我^^
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
Oldman
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 13:15:01 12/13/03 Sat
我都覺得係coke...因為supply有限...
而且，coke 又portable 同個罐係durable,
應該當罐coke只係一種貨幣，而唔應該當係飲品..
coke唔一定係飲，而係當money以物易物

>Which of the following things can best be used as
>money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples
>邊個係答案丫=.=?教我~~~
[> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
hi
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 17:22:13 12/13/03 Sat
>我都覺得係coke...因為supply有限...
>而且，coke 又portable 同個罐係durable,
>應該當罐coke只係一種貨幣，而唔應該當係飲品..
>coke唔一定係飲，而係當money以物易物

如果係當money，又點以物易物？
如果以物易物，又點會唔係當佢係coke？
仲有係tin of fresh coke，即係唔係空罐，又點會portable？
亦都唔會durable啦？

純粹討論，如有失言，請原諒...
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
jose
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 18:56:31 12/13/03 Sat
>Which of the following things can best be used as
>money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples
>邊個係答案丫=.=?教我~~~
1'm a f.3 boy too~
i think the answer should be (2)
because in the desert...it is difficult for those people to have the shells either for eating or using as money
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
7B24
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 22:31:02 12/13/03 Sat
簡單d諗
你係沙漠賣一隻駱駝
而冇貨幣的概念底下,你覺得以下邊樣值錢?
1)tin of fresh coke
2)sea shells
3)fresh apples
你會同意買家用500個貝殼去換你的駱駝,
或是用500罐可口可樂呢?
[> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
ok
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 09:42:58 12/14/03 Sun
>簡單d諗
>你係沙漠賣一隻駱駝
>而冇貨幣的概念底下,你覺得以下邊樣值錢?
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples
>你會同意買家用500個貝殼去換你的駱駝,
>或是用500罐可口可樂呢?
1,2,3都可以成為貨幣
任何野都可以,只不過係咪最適合jei
而且值唔值錢好似唔關事gar wor
響決定一樣野係咪可以用來做money只有果四樣條件及其特性
你咁樣唸係合乎邏輯
但係同econ就無咩關係wor...

我覺得係fresh coke<---響呢個欠缺水既沙漠, coke 係generally medium of exchange
因為shell<----唔係homogenous quality
apples<------not durable
[> [> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
中六甲班人
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 09:44:21 12/14/03 Sun
>>簡單d諗
>>你係沙漠賣一隻駱駝
>>而冇貨幣的概念底下,你覺得以下邊樣值錢?
>>1)tin of fresh coke
>>2)sea shells
>>3)fresh apples
>>你會同意買家用500個貝殼去換你的駱駝,
>>或是用500罐可口可樂呢?
>1,2,3都可以成為貨幣
>任何野都可以,只不過係咪最適合jei
>而且值唔值錢好似唔關事gar wor
>響決定一樣野係咪可以用來做money只有果四樣條件及其特性
>你咁樣唸係合乎邏輯
>但係同econ就無咩關係wor...
>
>我覺得係fresh coke<---響呢個欠缺水既沙漠, coke 係generally accepted as a medium of exchange
>因為shell<----唔係homogenous quality
>apples<------not durable
[> [> [> [> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
人
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 09:44:42 12/14/03 Sun
>>>簡單d諗
>>>你係沙漠賣一隻駱駝
>>>而冇貨幣的概念底下,你覺得以下邊樣值錢?
>>>1)tin of fresh coke
>>>2)sea shells
>>>3)fresh apples
>>>你會同意買家用500個貝殼去換你的駱駝,
>>>或是用500罐可口可樂呢?
>>1,2,3都可以成為貨幣
>>任何野都可以,只不過係咪最適合jei
>>而且值唔值錢好似唔關事gar wor
>>響決定一樣野係咪可以用來做money只有果四樣條件及其特性
>>你咁樣唸係合乎邏輯
>>但係同econ就無咩關係wor...
>>
>>我覺得係fresh coke<---響呢個欠缺水既沙漠, coke
>係generally accepted as a medium of exchange
>>因為shell<----唔係homogenous quality
>>apples<------not durable
[> Subject: Re: Economics高手請進!


Author:
old boy
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 23:27:23 12/13/03 Sat
is it a essay question ?
if it is
you can write any answer you want to
just have a reasonable answer and give clear explanations is ok

cause there is no strict answer for the essay question
so , no need to be so worry
[> Subject: 可能因為．．．


Author:
濟民5E-02-03
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 14:11:39 12/14/03 Sun
>Which of the following things can best be used as
>money in the desert?give three reasons for your answer
>1)tin of fresh coke
>2)sea shells
>3)fresh apples

簡單化咁睇∼
money最基本要generally accepted as a medium of exchange.
在沙漠2)sea shells應該唔係generally accepted所以唔得．

1)tin of fresh coke同3)fresh apples都應該generally accepted，所以要再作比較．
3)fresh apples non-durable.
1)tin of fresh coke is more duable when comparing to apple.
所以1)tin of fresh coke比3)fresh apples更加岩用．

Ans：1)tin of fresh coke

小弟愚見愚見~

[ Contact Forum Admin ]

Forum timezone: GMT+7
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.