VoyForums
[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

Mon, May 18 2026, 7:13:44Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1234[5]6789 ]
Subject: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
月 巴
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]
Date Posted: 21:30:52 04/25/04 Sun

上學期phy教mechanics的時候,袁sir都係教左某一topic先做果一個topic的 tas 實驗,如centripetal force那些等. 這不僅使同學做實驗時較易上手和做得較有效率,更可易於明白那些理論,若考試有問就更易作答..這對同學是有利的;

但不知為何到了下學期,phy明明是教緊waves, 但袁sir卻要我們做關於電學的tas..我們頭果一兩次當然唔明做緊咩,使peter哥在堂上十分忙..但袁sir的回應只是我們有責任於家中看明白才做..... 我個人認為這是不可能的, 就算勤力如伍仁杰都只是草草看過steps便開始做實驗根本不明白箇中涉及的理論..這樣的話做實驗還有何意義? 功利點來看,若果考試有考同學對實驗的理解 (如: 為何做centripetal force實驗的時候paper clip 不可觸碰到筆桿等 ←我不用其他電學的例子是因為我實在不明白實驗在做甚麼),我相信大部分同學不會懂得, 若果你在我們做tas堂時問我們正在做甚麼, 我敢說能答你的只有袁sir 和peter哥!這根本是有點兒浪費時間.

雖然我的phy不算很勁, 但我仍都堅信做實驗的目的是求證書本上學的theorem,加深同學對書本中的知識的認識, 所以我覺得phy tas應該要係教完先做, 不是做完先教.
我知道schedule已set好左, 要改變是很難的, 我只是在此發表意見...如果大家有何意見是做左先教比教左先做好,請回覆我..因我怕這只是我太單面睇.....

[ps: 我知道袁sir教書是很有心機的, 佢係每次電學tas前都有要我們看書提醒我們應注意什麼..但其實我們是 99.999% 不明白袁sir的提點而不是不尊心啊!]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:
[> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
i don't know
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 21:41:56 04/25/04 Sun

I hear the same complain from other schools ar. Somebody told me that even the same thing will happen in the university.
Most of us, myself included will be much more involved in the experiment when we know what is going on.
I do think those kind of experiment invloving electricity is somewhat a waste of time. But all of us should understand this is not the fault of our school and any of our teacher.


[> Subject: 同意


Author:
MAN1986
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 22:54:04 04/25/04 Sun

做TAS真係好無聊
問呀SIR同PETER咁做點解....
佢地ONLY話照做...唔洗問點解....
老實講...做完~如果唔明..都唔記得嫁啦...
第日先再教....都無用嫁啦....
SO做TAS對我地D PHY無乜幫左LOR...
仲有D WASTE時間....兩堂係度望住D野係度"牛"
又唔知袁SIR幾時黎扣分...
佢扣果D分....實扣硬既....
我地都唔明做緊乜....仲點注意D細節呢..?
自己番去預備?姐係睇晒有關D課本內容?
咁不如自修啦.....
我知呀SIR教書係有佢既難處
我相信呀SIR都知教完先做係比較好..
但可能真係TAS呢個制度有問題啦~呀SIR都有心無力....
我希望可以盡量改善啦....

[> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
past
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 23:01:14 04/25/04 Sun

>上學期phy教mechanics的時候,袁sir都係教左某一topic先做?>G一個topic的 tas 實驗,如centripetal force那些等.
>這不僅使同學做實驗時較易上手和做得較有效率,更可易於明白
>那些理論,若考試有問就更易作答..這對同學是有利的;
>
>但不知為何到了下學期,phy明明是教緊waves,
>但袁sir卻要我們做關於電學的tas..我們頭果一兩次當然唔明?>絢簬?使peter哥在堂上十分忙..但袁sir的回應只是我們有責?>籇颾a中看明白才做..... 我個人認為這是不可能的,
>就算勤力如伍仁杰都只是草草看過steps便開始做實驗根本不明
>白箇中涉及的理論..這樣的話做實驗還有何意義?
>功利點來看,若果考試有考同學對實驗的理解 (如:
>為何做centripetal force實驗的時候paper clip
>不可觸碰到筆桿等
>←我不用其他電學的例子是因為我實在不明白實驗在做甚麼),?>甯菻H大部分同學不會懂得,
>若果你在我們做tas堂時問我們正在做甚麼,
>我敢說能答你的只有袁sir
>和peter哥!這根本是有點兒浪費時間.
>
>雖然我的phy不算很勁,
>但我仍都堅信做實驗的目的是求證書本上學的theorem,加深同?>Л黈悒誘云漯壅悛獄{識, 所以我覺得phy
>tas應該要係教完先做, 不是做完先教.
>我知道schedule已set好左, 要改變是很難的,
>我只是在此發表意見...如果大家有何意見是做左先教比教左先
>做好,請回覆我..因我怕這只是我太單面睇.....
>
>[ps: 我知道袁sir教書是很有心機的,
>佢係每次電學tas前都有要我們看書提醒我們應注意什麼..但其
>實我們是 99.999% 不明白袁sir的提點而不是不尊心啊!]

絕對同意
去年is堂,幾乎每一次實驗室堂也有實驗給我們做.
但每一次全班也是於手忙腳亂下完成實驗,完全不明白箇中道理,更不用說對實驗產生興趣.
但當我在考試前夕,溫習is時才發現以往做的實驗是很有趣,對我但學習是很有幫助的,但當時因為對課題完全不了解,所以感覺實驗很悶
在教完全部範圍才一次過做實驗才是最好的學習.

[> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
天堂
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 18:28:53 04/26/04 Mon

我想話如果淨係pre-lab, 無睇過,無用過D儀器,
咁對做experiment跟本無乜用...

[> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
月巴
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 19:46:07 04/26/04 Mon

有同學誤會了我的意思了...我的意思是 未教就做 好過 做完先教 tas, 而不是 tas = 浪費時間~
不過今天peter哥也有跟我講過其實這也是制度的問題. 完全與學校或呀sir冇關.~
[> [> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:
MAN1986
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 20:50:10 04/26/04 Mon

>有同學誤會了我的意思了...我的意思是 未教就做 好過
>做完先教 tas, 而不是 tas = 浪費時間~
>不過今天peter哥也有跟我講過其實這也是制度的問題.
>完全與學校或呀sir冇關.~

我意思都係同你一樣wor..XDD
[> [> Subject: 打錯字


Author:
月巴
[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 22:17:51 04/26/04 Mon

打錯字..
真版:教完先做 好過 做完先教

[> Subject: Re: Form 6 Physics TAS 做緊咩!?!?!?!


Author:

[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 19:37:48 04/27/04 Tue

我都好認同呀...

而家做實驗真係唔知做緊乜,我認為我地而家ge程度係應該o係實9ge時候將課本上ge理論加以驗証。但而家就好似跟書照做,全唔各實驗知箇中意義及道理。咁樣書中理論我地固然唔能夠加以驗証,更唔好話從物理現象加以解析。

明白到自己o係屋企事先睇明晒d 野先做係幫助到而家ge情況,但雖知每日都有新知識,且要溫故。加上AL 一共有三科,仲有兩科極重要ge 語文科,每一科都要時間ge,唔係得一科physics,再加上有其他事務雖要處理,真係好難有時間事對實驗內容作先研究。同埋,就算真係有好多時間,突然間自己睇其實都未必明得晒...

好希望情況會有所改善。


[ Contact Forum Admin ]


Forum timezone: GMT+7
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.