VoyForums
[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

15:46:35 02/02/23 ThuLogin ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 123456[7]8910 ]
Subject: Re: 聖芳濟係天主教學校,但竟然支持同學慶祝萬聖節?


Author:
Edward仔
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]
Date Posted: 23:09:30 10/26/06 Thu
In reply to: 玩 's message, "聖芳濟係天主教學校,但竟然支持同學慶祝萬聖節?" on 19:30:34 10/26/06 Thu

>小弟係一位基督徒。
>一向有返開自己間教會。
>有次,有位導師指出,萬聖節係唔應該慶祝。
>
>
>原因有以下幾點:
>
>1。 萬聖節=魔鬼的節日,點解要慶祝? 想討好魔鬼?
>2。
>鬼同人係兩個世界,只要你唔惹佢地。佢地唔會搞你,但點解?>糬n搞呢次萬聖節Party黎招惹佢地?
>3。 萬聖節 = 西方鬼節。 如蘭節 = 東方鬼節。
>如蘭節當晚你地都早d返屋企啦,果日可以夜晚都唔出。但點解
>西方鬼節你地會慶祝?
>4。
>如果SFXC係一間無宗教信仰o既學校,都話無乜所謂。但門口有
>大大個十字架架喎。咁算咩意思?
>
>
>呢個問題我真係諗左好耐,麻煩各位俾小小意見。
>
>p.s: 想慶祝都唔=要搵鬼玩。
雖然話傳統天主教對於萬聖節抱隔離態度
但我對樓主意見有所保留
一.香港身為一個國際都市,中西文化匯聚,交織,慶祝西方節日(大部份)以是普遍ge事,就算係冇假放ge節日(如萬聖節),處處都洋溢氣氛,學校只不過想與民同樂,再者舉辦party都係想師生有更多溝通機會jei
二.萬聖節已失去佢原本ge意義。從前ge萬聖節的確係為左僻邪避鬼,但隨住時代演變,呢個節日已經漸成一個喜慶節日,所謂ge喜慶係歡喜,喜樂ge意思,已不再是為傳統的鬼怪了,那麼天主教(基督教)還需要有避忌嗎?如果你話盂蘭節就咁迷信唔出街,我認為呢D係因為人們在時間中堆積習慣ge成果。
三.如果你以咁簡單(宗教)ge理由就話我地學校批准同學接近魔鬼,未免令人不能信服。在此,我重申一次,我相信校方只為了能讓同學有機會與眾同樂罷了。所以同學只不過相互慶祝,而未必去找尋魔鬼,好比你跟壞人同行一路,我也不能說你跟佢地打交道
講笑句,門口咁大個十字架,乜鬼都俾你嚇走啦=.="
最後,我想話你知和尚都分文武或俗家弟子ga,武僧同俗家係俾飲酒ga~~

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:
[> Subject: Re: 聖芳濟係天主教學校,但竟然支持同學慶祝萬聖節?


Author:

[ Edit | View ]

Date Posted: 05:28:38 10/27/06 Fri

容許我在這裡分享少少自己的個人看法
首先想問,閣下有沒有任何證據證明萬聖節真的能夠招惹魔鬼? 又或任何事例證明普通萬聖節活動會令人撞邪?
沒錯,身為教徒是應該遵守上主的法律,但在遵守前,我想,最重要的還是要明白誡命背後的意義
遠離魔鬼無可否認是一件絕對的事,但今天的萬聖節已經是一個公認的娛樂節日,一個給予人們於繁忙生活中喘息的機會,而不再是一個宗教色彩濃厚的節日。既然沒有抵觸教義,且能夠使學生輕鬆一下,何樂而不為?
反觀盂蘭節,由於宗教色彩仍然濃厚,且與天主教教義相抵觸,所以學校並沒有鼓勵及批准任何相關活動
另外,我想問校方有否在萬聖節當天舉辦如'碟仙'等較敏感,及被認為會招惹邪靈的活動? 如果沒有,那麼就是單純的娛樂,我想教會是准許這類健康的娛樂活動吧!
最後,我想這並不是'慶祝'萬聖節,而只是托名'搞活動'


[ Contact Forum Admin ]


Forum timezone: GMT+7
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.