Fanciful rubbish. Give yourself an uppercut. -- Manly Haters Page

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time ]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 12:59:43 01/10/02 Thu
Author: CB
Subject: Fanciful rubbish. Give yourself an uppercut.
In reply to: Wills 's message, "The 'Proud' History of manly - Parts 4 , 5 & 6" on 20:28:56 01/09/02 Wed

>(In 1974, the era of Mortimer and 'The Entertainers'
>is born. Wills attends his first GF. manly aren't
>present, but Easts are... and that's all I have to say
>about that).
>
>(A Magic Dragon wears boots which may have been
>borrowed from a Wombat in the 1975 Grand Final.
>Naturally enough, the boots are cursed and the Magic
>Dragon bows out a Tragic Dragon. Now, who was his
>Australian Fullback understudy? Ohhhh, yeah).
>
>In '76, manly win the GF courstesy of their buying GB
>International Phil Lowe and the ineptititude of
>Neville Glover... but mainly through buying Phil Lowe.
>manly then show their long serving and loyal Captain,
>Bob Fulton, the door. This complete contempt of, and
>for, player loyalty is to become a trademark.
>
>(In the Year of Our Lord 1977, Parra and St.George
>draw the first GF. St.George then belt the tripe out
>of Parra to win the replay after a motivational 16mm
>film session involving the '73 GF. My contempt for Rod
>Reddy and, by association, St.George had commenced a
>couple of years earlier).
>
>In 1978 - having looted Norths of John Gray - manly's
>'73 lesson that thuggery pays is never more obvious
>than when they meet with Wests for an exhibition game
>in Melbourne that year. The manly-inspired brawl which
>ensues is a heavy set-back to the cause of RL in
>Victoria... but it gives Roy Masters an idea.
>
>This brilliant tactic is trotted out by manly often
>during the course of season '78 and provides them a
>Semi-Final draw with Parra. In the replay, Price is
>sent of by... who was it...? Oh, yeah - Greg Hartley.
>Price is later exonerated. Now, what else happened in
>that match? That's right - a game winning try was
>scored on the 7th tackle. "But Wills!" you cry "Who
>won!?". Well, dear readers, it wasn't Parra.
>
>By way of a Preliminary Final win over Minor Premiers
>Wests, during which a seemingly fair try to Wests'
>O'Grady is disallowed by the Referee (guess who?),
>manly reach the '78 GF.
>
>Despite what appears an offside try to Mooney (the
>Referee springing up from a forward-roll to award the
>points), manly can only manage a draw with opponents
>Cronulla. In the replay, manly win, but the cloud of
>controversy over the performance that season of a
>certain Referee hangs dark and heavy. Greg Hartley is
>appointed to accompany that year's Kangaroo Tour for
>his efforts that season. My research to determine who
>was heading the ARL at that time continues.
Wills, to see you typing this sort of rubbish is a little disappointing.
Not only Manly are the scum of the earth, but the performance of a referee is also something to hold against Manly? If that were the case every Parra fan would be justifiably ropeable at Canterbury given their free ride in the semis a few seasons back - Parra fans still talk about how the Dogs 'cheated' to win. I have always said that you have to take what comes from the referees, but no, obviously the Dogs must've colluded with the referee, given your allegations towards Manly?
We were very successful in the 70s and 80s. We played like thugs against Wests, just like they did. We played tough against Cronulla in the 1973 GF, and the tactics were successful.
Fulton was shown the door, or should I say, given the opportunity to expand his horizons, but he returned to the club as a master coach, so obviously he wasn't all that hard done by or he would never have returned to the fold.
To say the 1976 premiership was the result of us buying one player is totally ridiculous. Loewe was a good player, but so were Randall, Thompson, etc etc etc, the names were ALL great back then.
Your credibility is taking a hammering here old son.
You may dislike Manly, and I have no problem with that. But why twist the truth to make it add to your baseless agrguements? Manly were NOT the only club buying players to try and win premierships, we were just more successful than anyone else at it.

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:

Re: Fanciful rubbish. Give yourself an uppercut. -- Wills, 22:40:16 01/10/02 Thu