VoyForums
[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, 3, [4] ]
Subject: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
文匯報
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]
Date Posted: 02:25:16 08/14/05 Sun
 2005-08-14] 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜

　還記得2002年，當葉德嫻宣佈開演唱會後，便第一時間購票捧場。不過，今年她再開個場，已沒有再捧場了。

　事後，聽回她的《星之旅演唱會》現場錄音大碟，覺得成績及不上三年前的演唱會。首先是葉德嫻的歌聲，似乎未在最佳狀態，唱來平平緊緊的，就是選歌亦未見完善，許多首本名曲都榜上無名，換來的卻是大唱別人的歌，相信喜歡葉德嫻歌曲的歌迷，會覺得意猶未盡。聽完大碟，印象最深的是那個跟她合唱《美中不足》的男孩子廖書凡。

文：三點水

http://www.wenweipo.com/news.phtml?news_id=EN0508140025&cat=011EN
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
Dennis
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 15:24:19 08/14/05 Sun
一份不中肯的東西(絕不可以稱為碟評), 睇完之後, 我覺得可以不看!

極不客觀, 對人不對事! 我覺得如果只係出晒永恆, 唔出黑白既歌, 又唔知佢地會點寫呢???

咁"星之旅精選"夠收錄晒d炒碟既歌啦...我又未見得佢地有讚過一句叫人買碟囉...

前兩年有碟評話deanie唱得多英文歌, 唔配合香港市場, 今年, 唱多d中文歌啦, 又點呢???
為何張學友唱晒人地既歌, 就讚, 我覺得deanie番唱別人既歌, 唔差得過學友, 我說的是中肯意見... 不只我是deanie既 fans!
一張唱片, 係有比過心機既唱片, 會睇得出, 唔係亂咁出一張唱片, 一成不變, 大買既就叫好唱片! 怪不得多人download! 多謝傳媒!

而家d傳媒, 負面野就寫多幾筆, 好野就隻字不題, 怪不得而家香港人水平及知識不斷下降....對事毫無要求.

就近來為列, 我係bt講過一番說話, 是形容d人係bt download歌, 又大大聲批評人唱得唔好, d歌又leung! 重要串怪不得香港唱片業下滑既人...我形容佢地為"一個叫雞唔比錢既男人, 食完霸王餐重要唱個妓女床上功夫唔好既人一樣cheap"...無付出, 有咩資格去狠評呢?... 有時候, 不要只顧批評, 要多加許及以客觀意見另人再進一步, 香港先會win win....
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
Dennis
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 15:29:53 08/14/05 Sun
我可以用人頭擔保, 10年後, 只要有一個新人番唱"小城大事", 我深信一定會有人再提deanie 10前既"小城大事"充滿感情既演出. 無人可以否定....
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
彭彭
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 17:12:02 08/14/05 Sun
原本睇完e篇野都唔想出聲,因為實在太無奈.

不過我希望有一d寫碟評而未交稿既人可以睇到...

[多首名曲榜上無名],各位fans都知咩原因.

點解佢唔講下永恆點開天殺價.

佢要講fans既意見,點解唔黎e到做下資料收集?

相信可以做寫碟評既人,起碼都讀過大學,

點解佢諗既野仲幼稚過我...
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
carmanng
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 07:27:14 08/15/05 Mon
完本我都冇想過要回應的，呢份報導，跟本就不直一題。作為一個傳媒，佢的評論原全係唔中肯和有欠公平！！
（一）”今年她再開個場，已沒有再捧場了”
佢自己都話冇睇過呢個演唱會，《星之旅演唱會》話明係一個演唱會，所以我覺得鶡麆O者應該要去現場聽一聽個演唱會係點樣，先至去作一個評論和跟《星之旅演唱會》現場錄音大碟作一個比較。

（二）”葉德嫻的歌聲，似乎未在最佳狀態，唱來平平緊緊的”
其實呢張《星之旅演唱會》現場錄音大碟，大部份都係收鰷臚T場的錄音，其實第二場聲線狀態較佳，講野亦比較順暢。所以單單以只係聽現場錄音大碟的話，可能就聲線就比較沙齱C只不過係環球在選曲方面有問題!!

（三）”選歌亦未見完善，許多首本名曲都榜上無名，換來的卻是大唱別人的歌，相信喜歡葉德嫻歌曲的歌迷，會覺得意猶未盡”
本人亦請鶡黺ЖC記者做一儭禤こj集先至再講！點解許多首本名曲都都榜上無名？？鶡麆O者話有睇過2002年的演唱會，亦應該知道當其時的CD,VCD,DVD都冇收錄到許多首永琲犖q和Deanie姐一定會演唱英文歌(至於點唔可以收錄永琲犖q，請你自己做儭禤こj集啦)，而且Deanie姐話明呢個演唱會係向多位巨星致敬，當然要大唱別人的歌，所請亦你自己計一計數；
一) 佢要向多位巨星致敬，二) 要唱永琠M黑白時代的歌，三)要唱英文歌
所以條數係咁計數個喎，有冇錯先?? 以這位記者只係聽現場錄音大碟的話，係就係會更加覺得冇乜自己的歌! （因為冇收錄到最精彩鶪@部份，就係永黥X首歌，如果你有睇現場的話，咁就會覺得唱自己的歌和其他歌都好平均），但如果你地對鶡儥q星有偏見的話，就算成晚都係唱哂自己的歌咁又點!! 亦都可以話佢有許多首本名曲都榜上無名，但又唔見你地話張學友唱晒人地既歌有問題??

(四)"許多首本名曲都榜上無名，換來的卻是大唱別人的歌，相信喜歡葉德嫻歌曲的歌迷，會覺得意猶未盡。"
至於作為喜歡葉德嫻歌曲的歌迷，唯一會覺得意猶未盡的!!就係因為CD, VCD, DVD 都唔能夠收錄永琲犖q，會因為咁覺得意猶未盡和為此而失望!! 其實 Deanie 姐唱什麼歌，我地都咁鍾意，好似佢唱"小城大事"咁，跟本冇人比佢演繹得咁好和咁有感感情！！呢曮}叫驚喜哄I點會話冇驚喜呀！！

其實作為一個傳媒人，去評論演唱會大碟的時侯，好應該要睇
演唱會係點樣，做一儭禤こj集先至去作一個評論和跟現場錄音大碟作一個比較，咁就較為中肯。（雖然我作為喜歡葉德嫻歌曲的歌迷，亦好希望各位傳媒記者做一儭禤こj集先至再講，並請以中肯的和公平的態度去評論）
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
Edwin
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 08:55:25 08/15/05 Mon
其實也怪p得人地批評的,開法唱會連自己d歌也p可以唱,作為歌迷非常失望,p是歌迷的,亦會摸不箸頭腦,為什麼沒有那些hit歌呢? (尤其是Live CD),但這p是deanie的錯,就係因為牌權費過高,只能唱了那6首,而且不能出CD, DVD.
如果要看一個純deanie 靚歌演唱會,我想是沒有多大可能了,如果可以的話在2002及05 都做了,p會變成唱別人d歌及唱瑾有可从唱的自己歌.作為deanie嘅歌迷,可以看她這兩次concert己经非常滿足,始終世界唔係你想點就點,人地要hold住d歌p賣或開天殺價,也没他辨法.如果要完美.可能連這兩次concert也辨p成.
[> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
彭彭
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 09:59:05 08/15/05 Mon
其實,今次concert deanie 唱人地既歌我好仲意.
我唔係之前已經仲意e d 歌
(touch,紅,深愛著你,小城大事...英文歌...),
我係deanie唱完之後先仲意.

如果deanie今次唔唱人地既歌,唱曬自己黑白既歌.
咁之後既演唱會就無歌唱la~
而且deanie返唱人地既歌係好聽過原唱,而且會比fans一種驚喜.
[> [> Subject: Re: 葉德嫻個唱大碟欠驚喜


Author:
twister
[ Edit | View ]
Date Posted: 10:46:06 08/16/05 Tue
this is really too sad. i mean, what kind of critics we have now. who are these people to judge, while they even don't have the knowledge and can't differentiate good from bad! do they really know music or simply speaking, are they really into music? i mean, just look at their reasoning, so superficial and with no supporting. i think we can't just let these people override the public channel. perhaps, we should have our voice out in so other music forums as well if you care about good music if you care about deanie. it's all too good to see you guys posting you commetns here, but shouldn't consider posting it on some others forums as well?

[ Contact Forum Admin ]

Forum timezone: GMT-8
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.