[ Show ]
Support VoyForums
[ Shrink ]
VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 12 ]

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Date Posted: 22:03:11 03/07/07 Wed
Author: Rose Marie
Subject: Cozy Kittens & Sue Johnson scammed breeders and tortures cats

There is a lot more to Sue Johnson/Cozy kittens than most are aware of.

Approximately a year ago Rob Johnson of Cozy kittens posed and contacted me
as a pet buyer under the assumed name of Mitch Watson from Missouri. He gave
me a heart breaking story of his wife losing their white Persian pet of many
years named Casper. After several days of communicating with this character,
he convinced me to sell him two little white girls to surprise his wife
because she was so sad and depressed over losing Casper.
To make a long story short, a few days after I shipped the kittens to the
assumed "Mitch Watson", I get a phone call from a woman named Kathleen
to be Sue Johnson's ex accomplice in acquiring cats from several catteries
posing as pet clients and she described the entire transaction I had with this
Mitch Watson, whom is actually Rob Johson married to Sue Johnson from Cozy
Unfortunately I am not the only victim in this scam and several catteries
are involved where Sue Johnson has been acquiring cats from over the years by
posing herself or her husband or hiring others to pose as pet clients. Once
she gets our cats to her kitten mill, she then registers them as her own
breeding or has one of her accomplices from another cattery do it for her.
This is a horrific situation and CFA is very aware of Sue Johnson's
activities with formal complaints from those of us involved.
I have documentation from Kathleen of the horrific conditions these cats
are subjected to including inhumane termination of many cats by overdosing
with Tylenol and other methods. Some of the cats she illegally acquired from
several catteries have been brutally destroyed. This documentation has been
sent to CFA and the regional director for that region and it is being
This information is very graphic and sickening, therefore I will not be
posting it on this list. This slander against Florida breeders is because
where she conducted most of her scams and where "trouble" for her is coming
If anyone wishes to view the allegations that has been filed against Cozy
kittens/Sue Johnson with CFA, please contact me privately and "Please Beware"
these people are very good con-artists and they never use the same fictitious
name. They have been getting away with this scam for many years and they will
not stop.
These poor cats need a voice and a greedy monster must be stopped.

Barbara XXXX
>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>#2 CFA Protests
Barbara gave me permission to forward.........

Date: Thu, 1 Feb 2007 9:41:00 PM Eastern Standard Time
Subject: Re: [CFA-SR] Defamatory remarks on Web Page about FL Breeders

Donna, thank you for the support. The situation is really bad with this Cozy
kitten business and THEY NEED TO BE PUT OUT OF BUSINESS!!!!!!!!

This was a 'Wakeup Call" for me and I am not shipping any more pets unless I
already have an existing relationship. I don't care how heart breaking the
story is. OMG, this guy was sobbing on the phone about losing his Casper.
professional con-artists!!!! Not a day goes by that I don't get sick to my
stomach thinking about my two little girls and the Hell they're going thru.

Below is some of what Kathleen has filed with CFA. May be if enough of us
express our disgust with the situation and the word gets out where the potential
pet buyer can be educated about what really goes on behind Cozy kittens's
pretty website, we can do enough damage by exposing her "Dirty little Secrets."

Barbara XXXX

Kathleen Heineman
16397 E. Berry Ave.
Centennial, CO 80015

November 2, 2006

Cat Fancier's Association, Inc.
1805 Atlantic Avenue
P.O. Box 1005
Manasquan, NJ 08736-0805

Re: CFA Protest Form

To Whom It May Concern:

I am resubmitting your CFA Protest Form with special attention to Part V per
your instruction. I will attach an outline and documents to support false
registration of many breeders and kittens by Cozy Kitten Cattery.

As I was affiliated with Sue Johnson and Cozy Kitten Cattery for four years,
I can offer tangible evidence in select circumstances and convey my
participation in the transactions resulting in the fraudulent registration of
animals at
Cozy Kittens.

I have included letters from other breeders reflecting their experience with
Sue Johnson from Cozy Kittens. I have included their cattery names in the
event you need to verify the validity of their emails as attached.

In addition, I have listed, in outline format as requested, purchase
information of breeders obtained by Sue Johnson herself (using assumed names)
purchases made by me at the request of Sue Johnson. These purchases were made
with the intent to breed these cats without the purchase of breeding rights from
the sellers.

I am well aware that not all instances can be proven with supportive
documents. However, I do believe if you will invest the time to review just one
two of the many examples I have provided, you will find a consistent thread of
truth behind these allegations. I hesitate to direct your investigation but
feel there is ample support listed in Part V. Facts and Evidence - #3 and that
provided by the breeder, Linda Lawyer of Cats Creation under a separate Protest
filed earlier this year, to more than substantiate the patterns of under
cover purchases made by Sue and Rob Johnson.

I've since heard from breeders that such activities as I have described
happen all the time. These activities are far reaching in the area of the
accuracy of any pedigrees coming from Cozy Kitten cattery. People have
kittens from cats born in other catteries, or just born in someone’s house as
hobby, with the representation on the Cozy Kitten website that their kitten is
coming from a CFA Cattery of Excellence. There seems to be no consequence for
this unethical behavior which gives one a sense of wonderment about the
registration process itself.

Understanding that Doll Face breeders may not be held in the same regard by
the Cat Fancy as show breeders who breed to CFA standards, I have to question
if the same rules apply to both in accuracy of registration? Looking closely
at just one part of this complaint, you will see you have a show breeder, Pam
Allred, "hanging paper" on Doll Face breeders for Sue Johnson - Part V.
and Evidence - #15. Turning a head to these facts will soon distort the
pedigrees of Doll Face and show breeders alike.

In closing I have copied a statement and a picture from the Cozy Kitten
website. This link will take you directly to the CFA website where Cozy Kittens
proudly displayed. Interestingly, of the 8 pictures posted on the CFA
website, 5 of the kittens are from falsely papered parents. The kitten below
link is also from at least one falsely papered parent – see Part V. Facts and
Evidence - #10

Click here to check out
COZY KITTENS on the official CFA website!

I appreciate the time in reviewing this documentation. Please let me know if
further clarification is needed for any of the attached information.

Respectfully yours,

Kathleen Heineman-Mattox

Attachment: CFA Protest Form and detail.

Part IV. Forged Document

Attached document and explanation of the falsification of:

State of Missouri
Department of Agriculture
Small Animal Health Certificate

Issued 12/01/05

Sue Johnson wrote in an additional 7 week old kitten to ship to me with
another kitten who had just received a hernia operation 2 days before traveling.
To obtain the health certificate for the girl who had the operation, she had
her husband take the sister to the vet for the exam.

I continually offered to purchase any of the cats or kittens Sue Johnson
considered to be "problems" knowing that if they were left in the Johnson's care
they would be fed Tylenol or left behind a store in Kansas City, Missouri.

The Missouri Department of Agriculture has issued a warning to Sue and Rob
Johnson and said they will be watching future transactions from her cattery.

As discovered by the Department of Agriculture, there are 175-200 breeders at
Cozy Kittens. They have been in business for 18 years. The examples above
are but a small sampling of what has transpired to attain those numbers.
Mathematically, it seems impossible to know how many pedigrees have been
invalidated by Sue Johnsons business practices which, to date, CFA is
standing behind
in their registration process and by approving Cozy Kittens as a Cattery of

Part V. Facts and Evidence

April 2006 Shannon McGraw Meow House Kittens Letter of experience with
Cozy Kittens. These letters were sent to me as a reference to the character
of Sue Johnson.

May 2006 Paula Andersen Midwest Munchkins Letter of experience with Cozy
Kittens. These letters were sent to me as a reference to the character of
Sue Johnson.

December 2003 Cats Creation: Purchase of 2 Shaded Silver Persians At Sue
Johnson's request, I purchase 3 females from Linda Lawyer. Sue instructed me
just to buy them as pets and she would paper them somehow later. I have
attached one of the Pay Pal payments made from Sue Johnson to me on Dec 30, 2003
partial payment of Abbi and Grace. I believe Linda Lawyer has documented
this transaction in her complaint against Cozy Kittens as well.

The girls were purchased under the name of Abbi, Grace and Lilly. Their Cozy
Kitten's registered names are Kindness, Shimmer and Cinderella respectively.

October 2003 Wonderfluf Cattery: Purchase of 1 Chocolate Persian girl, 1
Blue Persian boy At Sue Johnson's request I purchased the above kittens from
Wonderfluf. Almost a year later, Sue requested the kitties be brought to her.
Mocha had delivered a litter born on 5/16/04 and Sue requested a baby girl
from that litter. My husband and I drove from Colorado to Unionville,
Missouri to deliver Blue, Mocha and their baby girl to Sue Johnson. All three
were “disposed of” by the Johnsons because they developed ring worm at their

Sue herself purchased 2 kittens under cover from Wonderfluf using an APEX m
ail address. These kittens registered names are Puddy Tat (black and white
male) and Garfield (red tabby male).

In the past few years Sue has befriended Joan Ahrenholtz from Wonderfluf and
purchased (with breeding rights under her own name) a chocolate point girl
registered as Love Bug and another black and white boy registered as Domino.

March 2004 Ecuarico's Cattery: Purchase of 4 kittens, 2 Himalayan girls, 1
Seal Point boy, 1 Copper Eyed White girl Under an assumed name, Sue Johnson
purchased 1 seal point boy who is now registered as Tarzan and one copper eyed
white girl now registered as Heaven As My Witness. I purchased the two
Himalayan girls for Sue Johnson. One died after having her first litter and the
other was taken to Kansas City and left behind a Wal Mart or Petsmart by Rob

November 2004 Christine Bernier: Purchase of 4 kittens, 1 Chocolate and
White girl, 1 Black and White girl, 1 Lilac boy and 1 Lilac girl. Under an
assumed name, Sue Johnson purchased 1 chocolate and white girl now named and
registered as Smores and one black and white girl now named and registered as
Salt &
Pepper. I bought the lilacs for her. I'm not sure what has happened to the
little girl, but Sue told me she had Rob take the boy to leave behind a store
in Kansas City.

June 2005 Robert R. Busch: Purchase of 4 kittens, 2 Shaded Silver Persians,
1 Blue Eyed White Persian, 1 Green Eyed White Persian Under an assumed name,
Sue Johnson purchased the above kittens for $150 each without breeding rights
from a little girl whose grandparents allowed to have a few litters of kittens
for some extra money. The Blue Eyed White Persian is now registered as Baby
Biggles or Mr. Bigglesworth and the Green Eyed White Persian is registered as
Paradise. Sue had her mother and her husband pick up these kittens from
Robert Busch.

2005 California classified ad: 1 Blue Eyed White Persian boy, 1 Odd Eyed
White Persian girl Sue purchased these two kittens and did not fulfill her
part of the trade to obtain the breeding rights from the California breeder. I
don't know the breeder's name but do know that Sue Johnson falsely papered
both of these breeders. Their registered names are Bright Eyes and Winter

2005 California classified ad: 2 flat faced white kittens I don’t know a
lot about these two kittens. Sue always referred to them as the "flat
California whites".

2005 Joyevan lines: 1 Blue Golden male, 1 Chinchilla male Sue's husband
Rob bought these two kittens under an assumed name with the pretense of them
being a present for his wife. I believe she registered the blue golden with
the name of Ahlo.

2002 Ramjoge Persians, Rhonda Fox: 1 Black and White Persian male Under an
assumed name, Sue Johnson purchased this male without breeding rights and
sold many litters of his kittens during 2003. His registered name was Pepe.
Many of his kittens developed FIP. Sue and Rob Johnson sold the ones that did
not die from the back of their van in a Wal Mart parking lot using a cardboard
sign to draw buyers.

2003 Katcraz line, Golden Persian Under an assumed name, Sue Johnson
purchased this male without breeding rights. She didn't tell me who the
was at the time, just that she had the Katcraz lines. As the kittens from this
breeder were mysteriously dying, Sue had her husband gave this breeder
Tylenol until he died. She called this cat "Against All Odds" but I'm
not sure if
that was his registered name. He was the only golden she had for a very long
time so any golden kittens (i.e. golden kittens born to Cozy Kittens Ellie)
would have been fathered by this male.

2006 Cindy Stump ,4-6 kittens purchased Sue Johnson
purchased these kittens from a local breeder in her area for $65 each. She
then sold one of the black kittens, from this group, through her website for
$2000 as a Cozy Kitten. She
clearly misrepresented that the kitten had been born at her cattery and
registered it in a litter of black kittens born around the same time. Details
the exact timing of this sale could probably be obtained from Cindy Stump.

April 2006 Correspondence with Linda Berg, CFA Animal Welfare My first
correspondence to try to put a stop to, or at least bring attention to, the
issues at Cozy Kittens were made to Linda Berg. Though a bit confusing, the
time in reading some of this correspondence will reflect once again as to the
less than reputable character of Sue and Rob Johnson. And more importantly,
the inhumane treatment or destruction of the animals at her cattery should they
show signs of disease or sickness.

This email refers to Linda Berg's findings that Sue Johnson was not state
licensed at that time as she had represented on her website. The State of
Missouri just issued a license to her in May of 2006 after attention had been
brought to her cattery by me and Linda Berg's department.

As Sue Johnson purchased two white kittens from Barbara Laffery of Furr-B
Cats, Barbara's correspondences is included in this section as well. Sue
purchased these two breeders using her daughter's boyfriend (an underage
minor). Sue's husband Rob posed as the boyfriend on a cell phone during the
transaction. Rob Johnson then took this underage minor to the airport to pick
both the kittens. This boy's parents were not aware of this transaction.

April 2006 Echo Lake Cattery, Pam Allred I have included the
correspondence starting on page 18 through page 24 which contains an original
email from
Pam Allred to me and my reply. Sue Johnson told me that Pam Allred had offered
to "hang papers" on some of the silver breeders Sue had purchased without
breeding rights. One in particular that was posted for a short time on the
website is named "Eclipse". This cat was purchased from Cats Creation by
using an alias name.

This correspondence is lengthy however I would like to point out the
statement made by Pam Allred on page 21 regarding papering a cat that Sue bought
cover from Arkie Paws cattery. Pam Allred purchased breeders from Arkie
Paws, a year later, that were the parents of the chocolate and white breeder at
Cozy Kittens. So, Im assuming Pam papered a kitten named "Chuckie" in a
up litter to accommodate Sue's request as stated by Pam on page 21.

April 2006 Correspondence with Connie Selitto, This
correspondence was my first attempt to bring to the attention of CFA the
"character" of Sue Johnson.

April 2006 Correspondence with Shannon McGraw, Meow House Cattery Although
much of this correspondence is venting between Shannon and myself, it is part
of my information to compile events as they happened over the past four years.

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]


Post a message:
This forum requires an account to post.
[ Create Account ]
[ Login ]
[ Contact Forum Admin ]

Forum timezone: GMT-8
VF Version: 3.00b, ConfDB:
Before posting please read our privacy policy.
VoyForums(tm) is a Free Service from Voyager Info-Systems.
Copyright © 1998-2019 Voyager Info-Systems. All Rights Reserved.