>Word count - MAX 2000 (give or take a few as we're a
>forgiving bunch)
>
>Homework is NOT critted, UNLESS specifically asked for
>and in that case, the usual applies where it would be
>appreciated if what kind of crit you're looking for
>can be mentioned.
I rather like the not critting unless asked for thing. I don't mind critting at all, but it's kind of nice not to be required to do so since, as we all know, a good crit takes time and thought, and sometimes I don't have enough time (or thought for that matter! *G*) to do a crit justice. And I think a lukewarm crit is short-changing the writer, and I don't want to short-change y'all in any way.
>
>And, I strongly encourage this, should be posted in
>their own thread. When homeworks are posted directly
>into the thread it originates from, the perception is
>that it's only good until the next one is posted, and
>that is not the case at all. And I'm of the opinion
>that a commitment of 2000 words, give or take a few,
>should be posted with the pride of ownership a new
>post makes it become.
True, that. Plus if the board starts scrolling like mad the homeworks get pushed off into the archives which means some of the posts don't get read or commented on.
>
>The library had, if I recall correctly, links to
>
>- writing sites members found interesting, insightful
>or instructional
>
>- reading recommendations and suggestions of books to
>refer to on craft
>
>- quick lessions on the basics, ie: grammar, genre, etc
>
>- a list of stories from the members on this board,
>(purely optional) the characters and a brief blurb
>about what it was about.
Thank you! I know I clicked on that link several times, but drew a complete blank when it came to the library. I also like Debi's suggestion of having links to the blogs of those who would like them there.
As for the crit link, I think a definition of the different kinds of crits would be helpful, along with how to give a crit (our way, which is nicer and more constructive than a lot of crits I've seen online!) and how to receive one. That way everyone would know what to expect, ie: if you ask for a hard crit, the definition posted will let you know how we'll respond, plus those who crit will know exactly what the poster is asking for.
>Seriously, I think it should be put back up that
>fanfic of DG's work will not be tolerated.
Absolutely! Especially with the brouhaha about it lately. That I can do without creating a new webpage.
>
>And I'd like a blurb in reminder that critiques, done
>properly, take time and patience and so a response
>could take a day or more. Also that we all understand
>that we all have real lives outside this board and
>that absenses are sometimes unavoidable. In such
>case, it's not necessary to "Clear the board" before
>you can post, but as soon as you are able, resume
>doing what you can to participate in all aspects.
Excellent suggestion!
>>
>[The FAQ] used to be in the format of question and answer
>with things like...
>
>How do I post?
>How often can I post?
>Do I have to crit so many excerpts before I can post
>my own for critique?
>How do I go about a critique?
>What can I expect out of a critique?
>What kinds of critiques are there?
>How do I ask for a critique?
>
>But in any event, I'd like to see answers that express
>things like...
>
>Crit the way you'd like to be critted, or specify what
>kind of critique you are looking for so we know where
>to begin. For instance, if I spend hours on a line by
>line, I'd like it recriprocated and not get a couple
>sentences in exchange, unless I ask for a
>generalization on something specific that concerns me.
>
>There is no limit on the number of posts, but to be
>courteous and comment on all the posts before posting
>your own work. That means general comments on the
>homeworks (unless a crit is requested), completing a
>crit to the best of your ability where necessary and
>responding to comments received. "Clear the board" is
>the best policy to encourage and motivate posts.
Well said!
>
>Well, hmmm. With more activity here, you'll be
>aware of the spam right away anyway. Right? Right.
>*G* But perhaps also a link to a couple members here
>that would be willing to give up their email addresses
>to be contacted with questions or suggestions.
May I infer from that I can add your email? *G*
>The only new thing I can think of is to have a link
>of homeworks past. A place to go when looking for
>inspiration or to remember with fondness.
I'll have to work on that one, because at the moment the only thing I can come up with is a separate webpage, and with that we run into copyright issues. But let me think on it and see what I can come up with.
Page