Author:
Dinh Truong Giang
|
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
Date Posted: 22:00:51 02/23/03 Sun
In reply to:
ndmt
's message, "Viet sau "vai y lang bang" cua anh D. T.G" on 21:57:32 02/23/03 Sun
Goi ban Tuong, Archicad cung nhu nhung ai quan tam
Xin dinh chinh voi ban Tuong 1 vai diem
Toi viet lang bang vua roi, la vi thay bai cua ban va Archicad co nhieu diem hay, toi cung da noi. Toi cung quan tam den van de day va hoc, nen khi doc xong thay co vai gop y. Trong bai toi viet, co cai khong ro la doi khi toi gop y voi ban, doi khi toi noi theo y minh ( khong nhat thiet ca bai nay de tra loi hay gop y nhung van de cua ban de cap ma thoi ) ne co the ban hieu lam vai cho. Toi chi muon gop y, viet them nhung cai toi da biet, trong do co nhung cai la khach quan ( co the tim hieu qua tai lieu) cung nhu chu quan ( la y cua ban than ) Toi hoan toan khong co y dieu cot hay gay cho ban hay bat cu ai cai cam giac "bai viet noi voi chung toi nhu la nhung nguoi khong biet gi ve KT", Toi xin loi neu ban hay ai do nghi nhu vay. Van de day, hoc , rat bao la, toi bao thi gio han hep, 1 phan boi di lam chiem mat thi gio, phan la viet cung khong phai de, toi viet vai y sau khi doc bai cua ban, cung muon ban them, va cung viet kha dai, ban dung nghi la toi bao thi gio han hep co nghia la khong de thi gio ra doc ma viet dai khai. Toi thay ban cung nhu vai ban tre trong dien dan co long moi dua ra nhung tieu de nhu vay, bo thi gio viet ra dai dong de nhung ai quan tam biet va gop y them. Dien dan, thi doi khi co gop y, co tranh luan, neu thang than va nhan su dung sai thi dien dan moi tiep tuc. Dau co ai hoan hao hay biet het moi dieu, ban dong y vay khong.
Vai vai diem toi noi ra day, de ban xem sao
Ban bao toi khac khe, khi sua ban viet Meuron. Heczog thanh Herzorg va de Meuron. That ra nhu toi bao, toi chi nghi la ban danh may lon thoi, khong phai thu tu ten la quan trong, vi day la 2 nguoi ma, ten ai truoc cung duoc, co dieu la HeRzog chu 0 phai HeCzog, don gian vay thoi. Neu ban nao danh may ten nay de tim hieu them tren internet thi co the gap kho khan. Do chi la loi danh may, 0 phai toi chi trich hay khac khe, chi sua lai ten dung vay thoi.
Va ban cung dung nen bao toi o vi tri nay no, cai ban bao toi co hoi ban co hoc o GSD , toi xin loi, that ra toi 0 biet, vi nhieu nguoi o VN qua theo dien du hoc, cung hoc nhieu truong hay lam, nen dieu nay la co the. Nhung sau do toi coi lai, va nghi chac la khong, nen da bo di roi, goi dien dan bai dinh chinh, co sua vai cho, 0 ngo la bai goi lai cung con sot diem nay, do la loi cua toi. Nhung ban dung nghi toi co y dieu cot ban hay ai het . Toi la 1 nguoi hoc va hien di lam o My, no 0 co nghia la toi biet nhieu hon ai hay gioi hon ai o VN het ban a, toi chi noi nhung cai biet cua minh o day de lam ro vai dieu ma thoi. Ban la khoa 96, ban cung co the da ra truong va xin hoc tiep o My neu co dieu kien, ban be cua toi luc truoc o truong cung den tu Thai Lan hay Dai han..cung qua day hoc tiep nhu vay. Tom lai , toi 0 co dung y xau hay dua cot dau, xin ban dung hieu lam. Nhu toi da noi, do la cho toi da bo, luc goi lai cho dien dan, lai con sot.
Ve chu KTS GSD toi chi noi theo toi biet thi 0 ai tu gioi thieu hay de tren card nhu vay ca, chi co trong resume cua ho ma thoi. Do la cai toi biet khi tiep xuc o day, va gop y vay thoi. Day von chi la danh xung, neu ban muon noi nhu vay thi toi cung 0 y kien. No 0 quan trong gi het. Toi gop y vi toi chua nghe qua tu nay o day ma thoi.
Ve chu nghia, thi cung kho, neu phan tich khac khe. Toi van nghi la chu "tham quyen" cua ban la "nang luc" do chu, va toi chi muon gop y la khong phai ban can co bang cap master moi co nang luc, hay nhieu nang luc hon nguoi co B.Arch. Vay thoi. Toi cung co bao la hoc them la dieu tot, nhat la truong gioi ai lai khong muon. Nhung hoc cung co nhieu duong neu ban khong co dieu kien. Toi viet kha dong dai ve chueyn nay vi doc thay 1 cau trong bai cua ban Archicad bao ..dau, roi hoc master, rang danh den sach.That ra y sau cung toi muon noi trong toan bai, chi la o cho hoc cao, bang cap cao la tot, nhung ban cung dung coi trong no qua, vi ban than no khong danh gia duoc nang luc that su cua mot KTS. Nhat la o VN nhu toi biet qua cac ban toi cung nhu bai cua ban Archicad cung nhu ban, van de dao tao cao hoc, tien si co rat nhieu van de. Nen chi neu khong vao cao hoc duoc, cung dung nen nan, hay so sanh, hay cho rang hoc cao hon thi thiet ke hay hon, chang han.
Cai "tu duy thiet ke" hay "y tuong kien truc" : ban noi la 2,. Toi chi co y noi 1 do an khoi dau bang y tuong, ket thuc thanh cong hay khong la co the hien duoc y tuong do khong cai y tuong do co the bat nguon tu "tu duy thiet ke" ma ban duoc dao tao, nhung no cung co the bat nguon tu rat nhieu nguon khac nhau. Va y tuong cua 1 do an, hay "tu duy thiet ke" cua 1 nguoi, cung 0 nhat thiet la tuong duong voi van de hoc cao hay thap dau. Han nhien do la y cua toi.
Khi toi viet ve y tuong va bao nguoi co bang master 0 nhat thiet phai co y tuong hay hon nguoi hoc thap hon that ra co y noi chung, 0 nhat thiet la tra loi ban... toi van tin dieu do la dung. Toi van tin la co "tai hoa", "Thien phu" doi voi 1 nganh nhu kien truc. Nhung toi 0 co y de cap den no nhung la 1 tieu chuan hay gi gi trong van de dao tao het. Khi ban bao ve nen dao tao di nguoc, hay cho do la ao tuong de tro khong xem thay co ra gi, thi do la 1 van de rong hon nhieu nua. Toi chi muon dua no ra de noi ve 1 nhan xet cua minh ve van de "sang tac". Toi cung da noi, y tuong thoi, chi ton tai tren giay, lam sao phat trien no thanh hien thuc moi duoc, va cai nay can kinh nghiem.
Van de thay tro, dao tao o truong nhu toi da noi, co 2 phia : phia duoc dao tao, va phia dao tao, ca hai phai co tam huyet thi moi tien len duoc. Tro ma khong khiem ton, cho minh la gioi de coi thuong thay co, hay thay co khong co nang luc de hoc tro vi ne, thi deu khong hay ca.
Ve cai "mong lung" ma toi noi, , toi chi noi nhu vay vi ban dua ra nhan xet 1 nguoi co PhD o Harvard la 1 Con nguoi kien truc,. Con tai hoa hay thien phu, qua la co mong lung, dua ra cai nay toi chi muon noi them 1 mat khac ngoai "su hoc", khong ai day duoc nhung dieu cho chung ta co Tadao Ando chang han.
Tai hoa cung chi la phan rat nho thoi, cac kien truc su gioi deu lam viec het long, kho nhoc moi cho ra troi nhung cong trinh hay.
Ve diem nay, xin muon 2 dieu nhan nhu cua hoa si Dali tuy la noi ve hoi hoa, nhung toi thay no cung rat thu vi khi noi ve nghe thuat noi chung
- La hoa si, thi hay ve di.
- Neu hoi hoa khong yeu anh, thi tat ca tinh yeu cua anh doi voi no deu vo ich
Day chi la 1 mat khac, toi khong co y dua no ra nhu 1 tieu chuan ve dao tao truong lop, co le lan sau toi nen ban thang vao nhung van de ban de cap thi ro hon. Nhu da noi, bai viet co nhieu phan lang bang cua rieng toi, chi thay la no co dinh dang den kien truc, hoc, va lam, nen viet ra vay. Doc bai cua ban toi muon noi them voi nhung ai quan tam, chu 0 phai bai viet cua toi chi nham vao ban, hay chi trich ban dau.
Ve chu "thuc te" hay "thuc dung", ban cho rang o Hoa ky thuc te, toi thi thay thuc te hay thuc dung, co the la ca hai. Y muon noi don gian chi la nang luc se duoc danh gia qua qua trinh lam viec, sau 1 thoi gian da biet nang luc, thi chang ai quan tam den bang cap may nua. Con toi khong hieu sao ban lai bao chu "thuc dung" "de cho nguoi VN chung ta"? Noi nhu vay la tot, hay khong tot ?
Thuc te hay thuc dung, cai gi dung muc du co cai hay cua no, trong doi song hay cong viec deu vay ma.
Tro lai cau ban noi "yeu nghe that su co the dong nghia voi chiu chet trong thuc te", khong yeu nghe thi lam sao hanh nghe tot ? Toi biet la o VN cong viec khong de dang. Nhung cai nay , co dinh dang den dao tao, phai co dam me ca thay lan tro thi moi co lop tre moi dua KTVN di len , dung khong. O dau cung vay, khi ra di lam tiep xuc voi thuc te, ca ve kien truc, lan doi song, nguoi ta deu bi rat nhieu rang buoc. Toi van nghi la can dao tao cho sinh vien de ho yeu nghe, chiu tim toi y tuong du rang thuc te 0 cho phep, nhung neu bien thanh thuc te phan nho cua 1 y tuong hay, van la tot hon la buong xuoi. O day, hang toi lam, van co nhieu do an rat chan, cung nhu nhung do an nhieu nguoi thich tham gia lam chang qua la de ton tai, nguoi ta cung lam nhung cai rat chan nhung dem lai loi nhuan, on dinh, trong khi nhung do an hay, co the phai chiu lo vi bo thi gio vao qua nhieu, bu qua dap lai, hi vong la tu tu se co nhieu do an hay hon nua. Thuc te o VN toi chi biet qua ban be va 1 thoi gian rat ngan di thuc tap, khong dam ban nhieu o day. Toi chi muon noi ra y cua toi, la trong kien truc, su mo mong cung la dieu can thiet.
No co the xa voi voi thuc te hien nay, nhung cung co the coi do la cai minh muon vuon toi, de roi rang di xa duoc chung nao hay chung do. Toi muon noi den chu yeu nghe la vi vay, khi ban vao hoc KT, ban cung co nhung uoc mo, ban cung muon theo no lau dai.
Yeu nghe thi thay co moi tan tinh chi bao cung nhu hoc hoi them de truyen dat cho lop tre. Yeu nghe thi lop tre moi co gang de vuon len. Co the cac ban bao toi 0 lam viec o VN nen de dang noi nhu vay, nhung toi thay day la 1 cai rat chung, dung o moi noi. Noi co dieu kien thi de dang hon, noi it dieu kien thi kho khan hon.
Ve thuc te va nha truong, ly thuyet va thuc hanh, toi cung khong muon tranh cai nhieu, day la nhung mat gay tranh cai nhieu trong van de dao tao o moi noi. Di hoc, phan lon cac truong, noi la co ca hai, nhung van la ly thuyet nhieu hon, ly thuyet theo cai nghia la nghien cuu va tren ban ve....con thuc hanh thi di lam van la moi truong tot nhat. GSD thi toi nghi khac o cho la phan lon nguoi quay lai hoc MARCH 2 la nhung nguoi da di lam 1 thoi gian, co khi da co bang KTS roi, co khi quay lai vi muon co co hoi hoc voi thay hay, ban gioi, hay quay lai ren them ky nang thiet ke..( thuc te co nhieu nguoi sau 1 thoi gian di lam, thay kha nang thiet ke bi dung lai hay di xuong, vi nhieu noi chi lam chuyen 1 loai, hay khong co nhung cong trinh thu thach hay di lam 1 giai doan nao do thay bot hung thu co rat nhieu ly do de nguoi ta quay lai truong). O day neu bao truong day ca hai , toi thich nhung truong co chuong trinh design-build, sinh vien thiet ke va lam that, tuy la cong trinh nho. Dien hinh la Rural Studio cua dai hoc Auburn( nguoi dau dan la KTS Samuel Mockbee da qua doi , duoc rat nhieu bao chi ca ngoi,..studio do ong dan dau da xay nhieu cong trinh rat sang tao, dung vat lieu re tien va xay cho cong dong dan ngheo) vi du ban theo 1 nam o day, 1 nhom sinh vien, thiet ke, xin vat lieu, va la cong nhan luon, cung voi su giup do cua dia phuong xay nha hay cong trinh cong cong cho cong dong dan ngheo. Toi nghi hoc nhu vay thi sinh vien hoc duoc rat nhieu, va nhanh nua.. Tiec la khong co nhieu truong co chuong trinh nhu vay.
Neu ban muon tim hieu chu Design trong GSD la ly thuyet hay thuc hanh, toi nghi ban co the hoi kts da hoc GSD ma ban da lam viec voi....toi khong hoc GSD, 0 noi duoc, chi qua ban be va dong nghiep hoc o do, thi dua ra nhan xet vay thoi, chu thuc hanh that ra 0 hieu ban muon dinh nghia ra sao, vi o day co nhung cai sinh vien lam that , nhung nho thoi, dien hinh la cac lop thiet ke ban ghe, con nghien cuu van de thuc te thi co nhu da noi, nhieu nguoi theo chuong trinh nay da co nhieu kinh nghiem thuc te roi, ho co the di sau them, nhung bai o truong van la tren giay to. Loai nhu Rural Studio nhu toi vua noi o tren, theo toi thi gan voi chu "thuc hanh" hon.
Ban da viet rat dai, toi cung co noi la ban co nghien cuu khi viet bai truoc. Toi co biet ve cac sach cung nhu kts ban dan ra khi viet ve GSD chang han. Toi khong bao la ban 0 co tham khao va khong suy nghi, chi muon gop y them theo nhung cai toi biet. Neu bao la khac ke hay dieu cot, thi toi rut kinh nghiem thoi, toi cong nhan co vai cho ma toi doc lai muon sua. Toi chi muon noi la toi khong co y do voi ban hay ai khac, toi chi quan tam ve van de nay ma viet vay thoi. Nhung gi ban viet cung nhu bat cu ai khac, neu toi thay dung thi toi rut kinh nghiem, neu toi khong dong y thi co the toi len tieng. Dien dan cung la de trao doi ma, dung khong ? Ban bao nhan tat ca sai lam ve minh va rut lui khoi dien dan, noi that toi thay ban hoi nong nay do. Toi 0 coi do la xung dot, nhung van de co nhieu y kien ban luan thi hay chu sao, no se giup nhung ai quan tam rut ra duoc 1 so dieu. Tuy moi nguoi thoi, neu la toi thi toi rut ra nhung dieu hay, con dieu do thi bo qua. Co the co cac ban quan tam thay nhung cai hay va do trong moi bai cua toi, ban, hay ban Viet Bac, cai chinh la thao luan hay noi ra, co giup ich gi duoc ai khong. Co ai dang di day o cac truong ktruc Vietnam quan tam den, va thay co nhung cai can sua doi de dao tao tot hon khong.
Do la ban ve dao tao, con chuong trinh dao tao o nuoc ngoai, hay noi ve GSD, co le chi la tai lieu tham khao cho nhung ai muon biet them.
Du sao toi thay ban cung la nguoi co long, va con nhieu thoi gian lang thang voi nghe KT.
TG
K84
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
|
Feedback: 