| Subject: Re: Official vs. Not Official |
Author:
TrekGOD
|
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
Date Posted: 16:05:25 10/17/02 Thu
Author Host/IP: NoHost/65.163.170.203
In reply to:
Warspite
's message, "Re: Official vs. Not Official" on 09:26:11 10/17/02 Thu
>>Ok, if we are going to have debates about what is and
>>what is not offical. We should recognize that if you
>>say that something like a Technical Manual is not
>>official then don't turn around and quote from it then
>>say later in the same message that it's not.
>
>The rules of the forum are clear. TMs are allowed, but
>if they conflict with the show in specific cases, then
>they are considered to be wrong in that case.
>
If you don't like the rules, then debate elsewhere.
every trekie's the same.
>>I've
>>read 3 or for things on this forum that some of the
>>more rabid trekies have said that was word-for-word
>>out of the ST: The Next Generation Technical Manual. I
>>have the technical manuals and I know what they say on
>>most of the subjects that we've discussed here. If
>>your going to say it is not official that is fine, but
>>don't turn around and quote from it when it serve's
>>your ability to make star trek look better. I'm not
>>taking sides but if you claim something is not
>>official then don't turn around and use it in the
>>debates. (YOU KNOW WHO YOU ARE) wrspt
>
>The rules are clear, and are on the website for all to
>see. I always stick to those rules. Again, if you
>don't like them then please don't whine, just go away
>and debate elsewhere. I don't mean to be rude, but I
>set this forum up with those rules, and that is the
>end of the story.
Ok, so you setup the forum to abide by your rules only. Heh, you close minded control freak.
>
>>
>>Furthermore, the Technical Manuals (no matter what you
>>guys scream and wine about being "cannon") are
>>official material for both Star Wars and Star Trek.
>>In fact in Star Wars eveything with the Lucas symbol
>>on it is official meaning that even the Role Playing
>>Material is officialy endorsed by Lucas Arts, Lucas
>>Films, Lucas Entertainment, Skywalker Sound, and
>>Industrial Light and Magic.
>
Actually, that is not true. Lucasfilm has de-canoned
(is that a word?) anything with the 'infinities' logo
on it.
and where the heck did you see or hear that from?
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
| |
Feedback: 