| Subject: Re: 「靈魂」根本不存在 |
Author:
Civic
|
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
Date Posted: 21:00:18 04/09/02 Tue
In reply to:
真田幸村
's message, "Re: 「靈魂」根本不存在" on 05:10:41 04/09/02 Tue
Sorry I'm not 爭論 with you, I just want give some more information.
May be I don't know type Chinese & my english not very good. Then let me try to explain more. I think you mis-understanding with my point. I may try explain its simple again. :D
1) I didn't try to prove 靈魂 is exit or not. Cos' most people didn't really see it before but some people & some 科學 such as 靈魂學 accept it is exiting. Who care it is exit or not. I just want to say, we all cannot prove how 靈魂 is wroking. So we never can try to explain it is 幻象 or it is 沒有感官. I know your meaning, but sometime & something we still don't know this whole world & this unversial, so we cannot just holding few formular to explain what we still don't know. I think "researching" is ok. For example, 1000 years ago, most people & our old 科學 believe "light" is transfer by cells. But now-a-day, we know "light" is not transfer by cells.
2) I know 風動,草動,心動 is by 佛家. And I don't mean "心動" is real our "heart". My meaning is "風動" ( people interesting on 靈魂 ) + "草動" ( some people scare on 靈魂 ) then "心動" ( then you post about your view about 靈魂 ). What I want to say, your post only anotehr effective of "心動" & may not be the real 靈魂's happen. It is becasue only "風動"+"草動"= your "心動" is not enough to explain our whole world. So I think your post is about your feeling only & I'm happy to read it! But I know it is not the 100% to explain the real things & I hope you to understand the "real ( or true )" is not cause by "風動"+"草動". because 風 & 草+動 only a happen in one moment that you can see & we all realize that it is not "everything". for example, everytime 草動 is cause by 風? the answer is no. but at least this moment you ( or me ) is "心動". I think I speak too much la! But I really hope you ( me & everyone ) can realize that everthing cannot see one face, we need to stacking around with a "reseaching heart" & everytime prove our view. Then we will finally to see our world is pretty nice & all of us are pretty !! Anyway, nice to talk to you!! :D
>>explain my point..... 風吹 is happen, 草動 is happen &
>>心動 is happen too. If you are 風, then 草 is 動 or
>>people's heart is 動?? If you are 草, then 風 is 動 or
>>people's heart is 動?? Actually, they all may 動, but
>>see what is your situation & how is your view. Maybe
>>nothing is 動, just see what happen is coming from
>>outside to the other(s). So from this point, you think
>>靈魂沒有腦細胞(更沒有感官), so靈魂」怎樣看天空, which
>>mean your heart is 動 by something you can only think
>>or you can only see. Tell me did you die before? If
>>you are 靈魂 & from your view to outside, 人 may only
>>got 腦細胞 and then nothing. So if you just speaking
>>about what you never seen before then what is you
>>speaking?? If you feeling something is not happen, how
>>can you tell about it?? If you touching something is
>>not exit, what can you touch?? If you reading
>>something which is not excatly is, then what is you
>>reading??? So if everything is not happen, how can you
>>心動?? Also, you never been 靈魂 or get answer by
>>靈魂, how can you 心動?? Also, tell me where is
>>actually "you" are & how can "you" 心動??
>
>不可能這樣假設如果人是草或風!
>人的眼睛當然是看到草動,這是情況...而用常識可知道'草'本?>迨ㄦ|動而推測到是風動,而實際上風本身也不會(自動),風的流
>動是天文現象,而所提到的"心動",不是指心臟,是指想像,
>{"not" people's heart is 動}~~
>草.風.心(臟)當然會動,不過你已曲解了我的意思,所以爭論是?>L謂的...
[
Next Thread |
Previous Thread |
Next Message |
Previous Message
]
| |
Feedback: 