>What day did Shandy write about last year? I think
>that, if this man existed and had been writing from
>eternity past, he would be infinitely far behind.
I agree. And, given your preconditions, this is neither paradoxical, nor absurd. It is merely a logical conclusion for the situation you've defined.
>So we have a dilemma on our hands. Either Shandy
>finishes his autobiography at some point or he is
>infinitely far behind. Which one do you choose?
As I said before, he is infinitely far behind. I don't see how this is absurd. It merely is.
>And
>what day did Shandy write about last year?
What day did he write about a thousand, or a million years ago?