Create a New Forum Admin Login Member Login Contribute to Voyager Search VoyForums Help Desk VoyForums Exchange VoyForums Directory/Categories VoyForums Homepage VoyForums News FAQ - Frequently Asked Questions

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

Thursday, July 17, 07:13:16pm

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, 2, 3, 4 ]

• In the last 15 years we have only produced 1 player who would likely start in our current team- Harvey Elliott - and even he isn’t a given. There are maybe 4/5 others good enough for this squad. I think people need to rein in their expectations of the kids (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 07:31:03pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
  • Can't agree with you at all on the list of players. I have 7 players from the last 15 years - Elliot, Sess, Carvalho, O'Reilly, Roberts, Dembele and Stansfield - better than players we had in our 23-man squad last season. Perhaps not all of them would be in a "1st 11", but then I'm not suggesting we have a go with the likes of King, Tanton, Sess and De Fog as primary players. All top players started as kids somewhere and got an opportunity to show what they can do. (NT) -- eganonoa, Tuesday, July 01, 07:48:27pm (cable-146-255-156-96.dynamic.telemach.ba/146.255.156.96)
    • Only Elliott, Sess and Spence have made a mark in the EPL - I think Dembele would have done. Fab and O.Reilly still v unproven and, for all his talent, not sure MOR is an EPL player. Roberts wouldn’t get close and Stansfield would only be a bit part player in this squad- not sure his on the ball skills are quite there for our level- although I hope I am wrong (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 08:04:18pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
      • All home grown EPL players start out as kids somewhere but the vast majority graduate from 5/6 academies and we have 3 of those in London. We have yet to produce anyone who is a regular starter in one of the major international teams (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 08:12:40pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
        • Blimey how far are you trying to move the goalposts here! I'm arguing for giving young players a chance at the literal fringes of the squad and have highlighted 9 players from our academy over the last 10 years who are better than certain players in our Premier League 23-man squad. Now you're criteria is someone playing for a "major international team." Don't think we're talking about the same thing at all! (NT) -- eganonoa, Tuesday, July 01, 08:19:07pm (cable-146-255-156-96.dynamic.telemach.ba/146.255.156.96)
    • Oh and Djed Spence and Mika Biereth (who we'd all be falling over ourselves with excitement about). 9 players from the last 10 years. All better than some members of our 23-man squad. That excludes Eze who wasn't with us nearly long enough to count. It also excludes Elijah Adebayo who I reckon if on the bench would have done a job for us in those games where we faced 10 men in the box. (NT) -- eganonoa, Tuesday, July 01, 08:15:12pm (cable-146-255-156-96.dynamic.telemach.ba/146.255.156.96)
      • Again I guess it is a matter of opinion- I don’t agree that most of the players you listed would be better than we had last season. I agree that 4/5 would be useful squad additions if we were able to keep them - which we weren’t- but we need to buy in better than we have in certain positions and most of those you mentioned would need to be eased out to make room for those coming in (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 08:35:41pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
        • I think the point I am trying to make is that throwing out random names from the age groups isn’t always the answer. I want eg King and Figs to make it - and if they do that would be great but 2 from the same cohort would be an outlier. That Figs got v good Canadian reviews is encouraging but having seen a fair bit of King and Taunton I would be v [pleasantly] surprised if they made it with us. As always, hope I am wrong with my assessment (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 08:46:21pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
        • Sess was in the squad already. O'Reilly and Elliot over Reed and Cairney I don't think is debatable. Any of Biereth, Dembele and Stansfield would easily replace Vini. Carvalho, Roberts or Stansfield over a perma-injured and on loan Nelson is obvious too. Spence over either Castagne or Tete. So 6 positions would have been improved. Besides all would have been very PSR-valuable if/when "eased out". The key is "if we were able to keep them". We won't ever keep anyone if we never give kids a chance. (NT) -- eganonoa, Tuesday, July 01, 08:46:36pm (cable-146-255-156-96.dynamic.telemach.ba/146.255.156.96)
          • We gave Sess Dem Fab and HE games. We could have given Robert more minutes but Symons preferred Kavnagh. MOR can feel harsh treated in that SP preferred Arter altho could argue he was too similar in style t TC and not as good as TC then and possibly now. Sess, Dem Elliot and Fab chose to leave although they had game time. Biereth likeOsmand chose to leave at u 18 level. We let Spence go for off field reasons so, for the most part, if they have been good enough they have got minutes (NT) -- f bloke, Tuesday, July 01, 10:39:29pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)
            • I agree we used to. And as a result we were positioned to cash in on the likes of Sess and Carvalho. But since promotion, there seems to be little to no space. We need to show that there is an avenue to games otherwise there's no hope we keep players and we'll lose more at 18 or so. Not advocating 38 starts a year. But if we're talking extending a 5th man, 34 year old to fill an occasional slot, I think that's a mistake. (NT) -- eganonoa, Wednesday, July 02, 11:16:01am (NoHost/217.75.196.3)
              • I don’t disagree but the kids need to convince the manager they are worthy starters now and justify a start over current first teamers. Both JK and Godo have had minutes and Figs may got some if he was fit. Stansfield would have done if he hadn’t engineered a move. Not sure who else is knocking on the door. Don’t think it is as bad as many believe (NT) -- f bloke, Wednesday, July 02, 12:04:26pm (NoHost/2.216.25.231)