Author:
TANK
[ Edit | View ]
|
Date Posted: 15:56:32 01/07/03 Tue
Just like Monday morning, I got up today, had a cup of coffee and thuroughly enjoyed the sports section of two newspapers...Life is Good when the NFL officials are apologizing to the OTHER team!
JJ Boss: Shockey has been dominant for 16 weeks, so I wasn't expecting Mike Rumph (Julian Peterson, Tony Parrish or Zach Bronson) to shut Jeremy down. Shockey is better than Tony "Pretty Boy" Gonzalez. In fact, I would say I was pleasantly surprised by Rumph. Do you think Jason Webster would have done any better?
I have looked at the list of free agent corners expected to be available this spring, and I have read all the initial draft material on the web (sad to see PFW's Joel Buschbaum pass away), and I just don't see a CB that will upgrade our pass defense unit in 2003. Assuming that Chris McAllister is franchised by the Ravens, there isn't a "shut down" corner available, and drafting at the 26th spot in the first round prevents Donahue from selecting an immediate impact rookie.
First Round CB Talent:
1. Terrance Newman (5'11, 175) Kansas State - fastest man in draft, the consensus top rated CB will be long gone.
2. Andre Woolfolk (6'1, 185) Oklahoma - extremely athletic, but converted WR, has only played CB for two years, ie., RAW!
3. Marcus Trufant (5'10, 185) Washington State - might be our man, but will he be available? (Jason Webster-sized)
4. Dennis Weathersby (6'1, 205) Oregon State - experienced, with some limitations...kinda like Rumph, but not as tough.
5. Derrick Strait (5'11, 195) Oklahoma - Huddle Report rates him a Top 15 player, but this junior needs refinement.
6. Nathan Vasher (5'11, 185) Texas - I must admit, I don't know anything about this guy.
Where is the answer to our pass defense problems? After those first three corners listed above, I don't know if one exists. Dre' Bly? Are you kidding me? Should Donahue go after Cleveland's RFA Lewis Sanders? It will cost us a draft pick. Short of some team with an early pick in the first round courting Steve Mariucci, I don't think the 49ers are in a position to improve on Plummer or Webster. Rumph's progress is the only thing I can hope for.
By the way, there are some players who are always injured, and some who always wear down by the playoffs. Wasn't Jason Webster slowed by injury at the end of last season, too? Isn't the Dave Fiore injury train so predictable that you have to make other travel plans? What about the aging Deese? When does the front office admit they cannot bank on these guys year in and year out with multi-year contracts and huge salary cap commitments?
Doug Brzezinski (6'4, 305) is a young, tough Eagles lineman who can play all five line positions and is experienced in the Andy Reid's WCO. I would not resign Matt Willig and Ben Lynch (combined cap figure of $2.3MM) and offer $2.5M a year to Brzezinski. Then, I would decide between injury-prone Fiore and aging Deese, with Deese's LT skills heavily in his favor. One of these big contracts needs to be axed.
Is Wayne Gandy an upgrade over Deese at LT? I see him as a more athletic Kirk Scrafford. Can Gandy be signed with some of the cap space saved in restructuring Terrell Owens' contract? If so, there is an abundance of LG options: Deese, Fiore, Brzezinski, Heitmann, Kosier, etc.
With minimal lifting, I can imagine an o-line of: Gragg, Stone, Newberry, Brzezinski and Deese. With some heavier lifting, I can see: Gragg, Stone, Newberry, Brzezinski, and Gandy, with Deese (or Fiore), and Heitmann and Kosier in reserve.
If Donahue doesn't want to use the cap savings from Terrell's contract restructure and extension on Gandy, then he should invest it in Vonnie Holiday, Daryl Gardner, Brandon Noble, or Cletidus Hunt. If Donahue cannot land Trufant or Woolfolk with the 26th pick, then he should consider drafting Cory Redding or Michael Haynes, and drop Vonnie Holliday from this list of free agent d-linemen. He also needs to make a decision about Dana Stubblefield. The original contract let the 49ers dump Stubby after this season without serious salary cap ramifications. I don't know how last spring's restructure affected this, but the original deal had Dana making over $4MM this year (March roster bonus included). I think some of those younger DT's might make a bigger impact and be more worthy of that kind of commitment. Cut Sean Moran, and keep either Okeafor or Engelberger.
|