Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Star Trek vs Star Wars

[ Show ]

Support VoyForums

[ Shrink ]

VoyForums Announcement: Programming and providing support for this service has been a labor of love since 1997. We are one of the few services online who values our users' privacy, and have never sold your information. We have even fought hard to defend your privacy in legal cases; however, we've done it with almost no financial support -- paying out of pocket to continue providing the service. Due to the issues imposed on us by advertisers, we also stopped hosting most ads on the forums many years ago. We hope you appreciate our efforts.

Show your support by donating any amount. (Note: We are still technically a for-profit company, so your contribution is not tax-deductible.) PayPal Acct: Feedback:

Donate to VoyForums (PayPal):

[ Login ] [ Contact Forum Admin ] [ Main index ] [ Post a new message ] [ Search | Check update time | Archives: 1, [2], 3, 4 ]

Subject: Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon)

Author:
Warspite
[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]
Date Posted: 16:54:08 10/08/02 Tue
Author Host/IP: ipd54b18d5.free.wxs.nl/213.75.24.213
In reply to: Warspite 's message, "New poll (Nebula v Nebulon)" on 10:38:32 10/07/02 Mon

>There is a new poll up.
>
>A Star Trek Nebula class starship faces a Nebulon B
>class ship inside a Mutara nebula. Who wins?

Bear in mind that nebulas don't seem to affect TNG Federation ships the way they seemed to affect them at the time of ST:WoK. We have seen ships go into nebulas, and shields and sensors still work. At worst, sensors are still mildly disrupted, but not to the same extent as in TOS.

Also bear in mind that if the Nebula ship has a war pod, it has much more firepower than a Galaxy class. The warpod has something like 8 torpedo tubes, each of which has been shown to be capable of firing at least three torpedoes per salvo. That is of course in addition to it's standard integral weaponry (8 type X phasers and 2 torpedo launchers). If the pod launchers are the same as the internal launchers (capable of firing 10 torps per salvo), you could potentially have a torpedo salvo of 100 torpedoes! (Ouch!)

Even if they are only capable of three per salvo (as we have seen), you would still have 44 torpedoes per salvo! That's enough to take the starch out of anyone. :)

On the down side (for the Feds), the nebula would probably prevent long range torpedo fire.

I think that if its a war-Nebula, it will win easily. A standard Nebula will have its work cut out.

[ Next Thread | Previous Thread | Next Message | Previous Message ]

Replies:

Subject Author Date

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) Warspite 10:38:38 10/11/02 Fri

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 04:32:32 10/12/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 12:45:54 10/12/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 19:08:20 10/12/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 23:13:52 10/12/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 04:21:13 10/13/02 Sun

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- bob, 02:14:19 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- NeutralZone, 13:27:40 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 15:19:20 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 15:25:21 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 16:33:42 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- NeutralZone, 17:11:30 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- bob, 20:26:18 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 00:10:22 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 00:08:00 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- bob, 22:10:27 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 03:35:21 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- slides are fun, 03:17:07 10/19/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 16:51:14 10/19/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:25:00 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 13:56:35 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 15:07:15 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 13:51:31 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 16:19:39 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 04:05:57 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:53:19 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 02:07:58 10/18/02 Fri

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 15:18:17 10/19/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 17:22:51 10/19/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:53:41 10/21/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 03:23:16 10/22/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:10:02 10/22/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:46:02 10/22/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 22:39:02 10/22/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:33:43 10/23/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 04:59:10 10/24/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:50:42 10/24/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 14:00:43 10/24/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 18:46:53 10/24/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 23:22:02 10/24/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 08:34:30 10/25/02 Fri

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 22:58:10 10/25/02 Fri

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 02:07:34 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 10:03:21 10/15/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 06:28:18 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:53:02 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 19:03:01 10/16/02 Wed

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- NeutralZone, 12:26:35 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 02:12:11 10/18/02 Fri
Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 21:21:30 10/19/02 Sat

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 13:45:39 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 21:54:01 10/19/02 Sat
Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- capn hayes, 02:50:23 10/20/02 Sun

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 14:50:35 10/21/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- TrekGOD, 08:59:34 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 10:13:48 10/17/02 Thu

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- TrekGOD, 04:00:59 10/21/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 14:57:13 10/21/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- TrekGOD, 17:14:45 10/21/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- Warspite, 09:15:02 10/22/02 Tue

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 02:16:03 10/18/02 Fri

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 16:14:28 10/14/02 Mon

Re: New poll (Nebula v Nebulon) -- The Divine Shadow, 16:12:39 10/14/02 Mon